Youth historical thinking about "gender" from the Capricho magazine (2005-2006)

Detalhes bibliográficos
Autor(a) principal: Mantovani, Flavia
Data de Publicação: 2014
Tipo de documento: Artigo
Idioma: por
Título da fonte: Antíteses
Texto Completo: https://ojs.uel.br/revistas/uel/index.php/antiteses/article/view/20554
Resumo: The objective is to investigate the historical thinking of young people about “gender”, from the magazine Capricho (Apr/2005-Mar/2006), using it as a historical source. It is interesting to observe if they built a “historical literacy” and if they mobilized it in their reading practices, considering such literacy as a way of reading and interpreting the world historically. The apprehension of these ideas took place through a didactic-pedagogical practice, based on the school use of historical sources, in which the "historical literacy" of students of the second year "A" of High School at Colégio de Aplicação - Londrina/ PR, in relation to this magazine. The technique of focus groups was used, interposed to the assumptions of the class-workshop, seeking to develop an interpretation/reading of the sources and their contextualized understanding. In three recorded and transcribed classes, previous ideas were collected from students and their interpretations of the source, through which the construction of a historical literacy is worked. It is necessary to problematize and analyze, in the historical perspective, of this subject who is researched, the students of the "2nd A", under the assumption that adolescence is a discursive construction and a cultural phenomenon, that is, this problem is problematized. group of subjects, adolescents, in order to denaturalize them. Thus, the relationship of these young people with the gender issue is approached, taking the school space as important in the construction of this relationship and, also, in the production of differences. In a second moment, Capricho magazine and the various dimensions it assumes in this research are discussed, that is, as a product of the media culture that asks for an evaluation that includes, including, the dimension of its appropriation, or even, of the uses and students' interpretations. The time frame was chosen due to the existence of an editorial standard in relation to the identity of the young woman: the analyzed editions show the concern with a given authenticity of the reader, through the slogan “be different, be you”. Also, Capricho magazine is understood as a historical source used in a school context. Supported by references from the field of History and Communication, it is understood the relationship between Capricho and readers in its complexity, both build each other recursively, they are interdependent. From this idea, it is possible to think and problematize not only the media as a producer of gender pedagogies, but also the public as a co-producer of the magazine, since it appropriates its cultural codes, in order not to clash with the horizon. expectations of your readers. Finally, it is based on references from the investigative field of Historical Education, where it seeks to investigate, also, how the historical learning of the subjects takes place. Still, the concept of “historical literacy” coined by Peter Lee is used, in an analysis of students' speeches about gender and sexuality issues at Capricho. It was noticed that students already bring ideas and notions about gender and that such ideas reproduce, to a certain extent, a conservative conception. However, they demonstrate the ability to observe and historicize the gender issues that Capricho brings, reading it as a historical source, that is, contextualizing their discourses, which means a “historical literacy”.
id UEL-13_fce8a2a5665f1ae50aba7f8368de2b92
oai_identifier_str oai:ojs.pkp.sfu.ca:article/20554
network_acronym_str UEL-13
network_name_str Antíteses
repository_id_str
spelling Youth historical thinking about "gender" from the Capricho magazine (2005-2006)Juventud pensamiento histórico sobre "género" de la revista Capricho (2005-2006).Pensamento histórico de jovens sobre “gênero” a partir da revista Capricho (2005-2006)Historical literacyCapricho magazineMedia cultureTeaching history and genderAlfabetización históricaRevista CaprichoCultura mediáticaEnseñanza de la historia y el géneroLiteracia históricaRevista CaprichoCultura midiáticaEnsino de história e gêneroThe objective is to investigate the historical thinking of young people about “gender”, from the magazine Capricho (Apr/2005-Mar/2006), using it as a historical source. It is interesting to observe if they built a “historical literacy” and if they mobilized it in their reading practices, considering such literacy as a way of reading and interpreting the world historically. The apprehension of these ideas took place through a didactic-pedagogical practice, based on the school use of historical sources, in which the "historical literacy" of students of the second year "A" of High School at Colégio de Aplicação - Londrina/ PR, in relation to this magazine. The technique of focus groups was used, interposed to the assumptions of the class-workshop, seeking to develop an interpretation/reading of the sources and their contextualized understanding. In three recorded and transcribed classes, previous ideas were collected from students and their interpretations of the source, through which the construction of a historical literacy is worked. It is necessary to problematize and analyze, in the historical perspective, of this subject who is researched, the students of the "2nd A", under the assumption that adolescence is a discursive construction and a cultural phenomenon, that is, this problem is problematized. group of subjects, adolescents, in order to denaturalize them. Thus, the relationship of these young people with the gender issue is approached, taking the school space as important in the construction of this relationship and, also, in the production of differences. In a second moment, Capricho magazine and the various dimensions it assumes in this research are discussed, that is, as a product of the media culture that asks for an evaluation that includes, including, the dimension of its appropriation, or even, of the uses and students' interpretations. The time frame was chosen due to the existence of an editorial standard in relation to the identity of the young woman: the analyzed editions show the concern with a given authenticity of the reader, through the slogan “be different, be you”. Also, Capricho magazine is understood as a historical source used in a school context. Supported by references from the field of History and Communication, it is understood the relationship between Capricho and readers in its complexity, both build each other recursively, they are interdependent. From this idea, it is possible to think and problematize not only the media as a producer of gender pedagogies, but also the public as a co-producer of the magazine, since it appropriates its cultural codes, in order not to clash with the horizon. expectations of your readers. Finally, it is based on references from the investigative field of Historical Education, where it seeks to investigate, also, how the historical learning of the subjects takes place. Still, the concept of “historical literacy” coined by Peter Lee is used, in an analysis of students' speeches about gender and sexuality issues at Capricho. It was noticed that students already bring ideas and notions about gender and that such ideas reproduce, to a certain extent, a conservative conception. However, they demonstrate the ability to observe and historicize the gender issues that Capricho brings, reading it as a historical source, that is, contextualizing their discourses, which means a “historical literacy”.El objetivo es investigar el pensamiento histórico de jóvenes sobre el “género” tomando como punto de partida la  revista Capricho (abr/2005-mar/2006), la utilizando como una fuente histórica. Interesa observar si construyeron una “alfabetización histórica” y la movilizan en sus prácticas de lectura, considerando la alfabetización histórica la como una manera de leer e interpretar el mundo históricamente. La aprehensión de las ideas ha  ocurrido  a través de una práctica didáctica y pedagógica, basada en el uso de la las fuentes históricas en contexto escolar, en el que examina la "alfabetización histórica" con respecto a Capricho, de los estudiantes del segundo año "A" de la escuela secundaria “Colégio de Aplicação” – Londrina/PR. Se utilizó la técnica de grupos focales superpuesta a la propuesta del clase-taller, desenvolviendo la interpretación/lectura de las fuentes y su comprensión contextual.  En tres clases grabadas y transcritas, se recogió ideas las ideas previas de los alumnos y sus interpretaciones de la fuente, a través del cual trabaja para construir una alfabetización histórica. Es necesario una problematización y el análisis, desde una perspectiva histórica, de este sujeto el cual se estudia, los/las estudiantes del “2ºA”, bajo el supuesto de que la adolescencia es una construcción discursiva y un fenómeno cultural, en otras palabras, problematiza este grupo de sujetos, los adolescentes, con el fin de desnaturalizar ellos. El enfoque es las relaciones de estos jóvenes con las cuestiones de género, tomando la escuela como importante en la construcción de esta relación y también la producción de diferencias. En un segundo paso, se discute la revista Capricho y las diversas dimensiones que asume esta investigación, es decir, como un producto de la cultura mediática que aboga por una revisión que abarca, incluyendo la extensión de su apropiación, o, los usos y interpretaciones de los estudiantes. La elección del marco de tiempo ocurrió debido a la existencia de normas editoriales relativas a la identidad de los jóvenes: las revistas analizadas demuestran la preocupación por una autenticidad dada del lector, a través del lema "Sé diferente, ser tú."Además, la revista Capricho es entendida como una fuente histórica utilizada en el contexto escolar. Apoyado en referenciales de la Historia y de la Comunicación, si piensa la relación entre los lectores y Capricho en su complejidad, se construye una a la otra, de forma recursiva, son interdependientes. A partir de esta idea, es posible pensar y cuestionar no sólo los medios de comunicación como productores de las pedagogías de género, sino al público como co-productor de la revista, ya que se apropia de sus códigos culturales, a fin de no entrar en conflicto con las expectativas de sus lectores. De todos modos, se basa en las referencias del campo de investigativo de la Educación Histórica donde también pretende investigar cómo es el aprendizaje del sujeto acerca de la historia. También utiliza el concepto de "alfabetización histórica" acuñado por Peter Lee, en un análisis del discurso de los estudiantes en temas de género y sexualidad en la Capricho. Se observó que los estudiantes ya traen ideas y nociones sobre el género y que tales ideas se reproducen, en cierta medida, un diseño conservador. Sin embargo, demostran la capacidad de observar y ubicar históricamente las cuestiones de género que trae Capricho, la leendo como fuente histórica, es decir, la contextualización de sus discursos, lo que significa una "alfabetización histórica".Objetiva-se investigar a o pensamento histórico de jovens sobre “gênero”, a partir da revista Capricho (abr/2005-mar/2006), utilizando-a como uma fonte histórica. Interessa observar se construíram uma “literacia histórica” e se a mobilizam nas suas práticas de leitura, considerando tal literacia como um modo de ler e interpretar o mundo historicamente. A apreensão destas ideias deu-se através de uma prática didático-pedagógica, pautada no uso escolar de fontes históricas, na qual se analisa a “literacia histórica” de estudantes do segundo ano “A” do Ensino Médio do Colégio de Aplicação – Londrina/PR, em relação a esta revista. Utilizou-se a técnica de grupos focais interposta aos pressupostos da aula-oficina, buscando desenvolver uma interpretação/leitura das fontes e sua compreensão contextualizada. Em três aulas gravadas e transcritas, coletou-se ideias prévias de estudantes e suas interpretações da fonte, através da qual trabalha-se a construção de uma literacia histórica. É necessária uma problematização e análise, na perspectiva histórica, deste sujeito o qual se pesquisa, os/as estudantes do “2ºA”, sob o pressuposto de que a adolescência é uma construção discursiva e um fenômenos cultural, ou seja, problematiza-se este grupo de sujeitos, adolescentes, de modo a desnaturalizá-los. Assim, aborda-se as relações destes jovens com a questão de gênero, tomando o espaço escolar como importante na construção desta relação e, ainda, na produção das diferenças. Em um segundo momento, discute-se a revista Capricho e as várias dimensões que assume nesta pesquisa, isto é, como um produto da cultura midiática que pede uma avaliação que abarque, inclusive, a dimensão da sua apropriação, ou ainda, dos usos e interpretações dos estudantes. A escolha do recorte temporal deu-se em função da existência de um padrão editorial em relação à identidade da jovem: as edições analisadas evidenciam a preocupação com uma dada autenticidade da leitora, através do slogan “seja diferente, seja você”. Também, a revista Capricho é entendida como fonte histórica utilizada em contexto escolar. Apoiados em referenciais do campo da História e da Comunicação, entende-se a relação entre Capricho e leitoras em sua complexidade, ambas constroem uma a outra recursivamente, são interdependentes. A partir desta ideia, é possível pensar e problematizar não apenas a mídia enquanto produtora de pedagogias de gênero, mas também a o público enquanto um co-produtor da revista, já que esta se apropria dos seus códigos culturais, a fim de não destoar do horizonte de expectativas de suas leitoras. Enfim, apoia-se em referenciais do campo investigativo da Educação Histórica, onde se procura investigar, também, como se dá o aprendizado histórico dos sujeitos. Ainda, utiliza-se o conceito de “literacia histórica” cunhado por Peter Lee, em uma análise das falas de alunos sobre questões de gênero e sexualidade na Capricho. Percebeu-se que os alunos já trazem ideias e noções sobre gênero e que tais ideias reproduzem, em certa medida, uma concepção conservadora. Entretanto, demonstram capacidade de observar e historicizar as questões de gênero que a Capricho traz, lendo-a como uma fonte histórica, ou seja, contextualizando seus discursos, o que significa uma “literacia histórica”.Universidade Estadual de Londrina2014-12-19info:eu-repo/semantics/articleinfo:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersionapplication/pdfhttps://ojs.uel.br/revistas/uel/index.php/antiteses/article/view/2055410.5433/1984-3356.2014v7n14p534Antíteses; Vol. 7 No. 14 (2014): Histórias e Antropologias dos Patrimônios Culturais; 534-536Antíteses; v. 7 n. 14 (2014): Histórias e Antropologias dos Patrimônios Culturais; 534-5361984-3356reponame:Antítesesinstname:Universidade Estadual de Londrina (UEL)instacron:UELporhttps://ojs.uel.br/revistas/uel/index.php/antiteses/article/view/20554/15641Copyright (c) 2014 Antíteseshttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccessMantovani, Flavia2022-11-03T17:54:40Zoai:ojs.pkp.sfu.ca:article/20554Revistahttps://www.uel.br/revistas/uel/index.php/antitesesPUBhttps://www.uel.br/revistas/uel/index.php/antiteses/oaiantiteses@uel.br||1984-33561984-3356opendoar:2022-11-03T17:54:40Antíteses - Universidade Estadual de Londrina (UEL)false
dc.title.none.fl_str_mv Youth historical thinking about "gender" from the Capricho magazine (2005-2006)
Juventud pensamiento histórico sobre "género" de la revista Capricho (2005-2006).
Pensamento histórico de jovens sobre “gênero” a partir da revista Capricho (2005-2006)
title Youth historical thinking about "gender" from the Capricho magazine (2005-2006)
spellingShingle Youth historical thinking about "gender" from the Capricho magazine (2005-2006)
Mantovani, Flavia
Historical literacy
Capricho magazine
Media culture
Teaching history and gender
Alfabetización histórica
Revista Capricho
Cultura mediática
Enseñanza de la historia y el género
Literacia histórica
Revista Capricho
Cultura midiática
Ensino de história e gênero
title_short Youth historical thinking about "gender" from the Capricho magazine (2005-2006)
title_full Youth historical thinking about "gender" from the Capricho magazine (2005-2006)
title_fullStr Youth historical thinking about "gender" from the Capricho magazine (2005-2006)
title_full_unstemmed Youth historical thinking about "gender" from the Capricho magazine (2005-2006)
title_sort Youth historical thinking about "gender" from the Capricho magazine (2005-2006)
author Mantovani, Flavia
author_facet Mantovani, Flavia
author_role author
dc.contributor.author.fl_str_mv Mantovani, Flavia
dc.subject.por.fl_str_mv Historical literacy
Capricho magazine
Media culture
Teaching history and gender
Alfabetización histórica
Revista Capricho
Cultura mediática
Enseñanza de la historia y el género
Literacia histórica
Revista Capricho
Cultura midiática
Ensino de história e gênero
topic Historical literacy
Capricho magazine
Media culture
Teaching history and gender
Alfabetización histórica
Revista Capricho
Cultura mediática
Enseñanza de la historia y el género
Literacia histórica
Revista Capricho
Cultura midiática
Ensino de história e gênero
description The objective is to investigate the historical thinking of young people about “gender”, from the magazine Capricho (Apr/2005-Mar/2006), using it as a historical source. It is interesting to observe if they built a “historical literacy” and if they mobilized it in their reading practices, considering such literacy as a way of reading and interpreting the world historically. The apprehension of these ideas took place through a didactic-pedagogical practice, based on the school use of historical sources, in which the "historical literacy" of students of the second year "A" of High School at Colégio de Aplicação - Londrina/ PR, in relation to this magazine. The technique of focus groups was used, interposed to the assumptions of the class-workshop, seeking to develop an interpretation/reading of the sources and their contextualized understanding. In three recorded and transcribed classes, previous ideas were collected from students and their interpretations of the source, through which the construction of a historical literacy is worked. It is necessary to problematize and analyze, in the historical perspective, of this subject who is researched, the students of the "2nd A", under the assumption that adolescence is a discursive construction and a cultural phenomenon, that is, this problem is problematized. group of subjects, adolescents, in order to denaturalize them. Thus, the relationship of these young people with the gender issue is approached, taking the school space as important in the construction of this relationship and, also, in the production of differences. In a second moment, Capricho magazine and the various dimensions it assumes in this research are discussed, that is, as a product of the media culture that asks for an evaluation that includes, including, the dimension of its appropriation, or even, of the uses and students' interpretations. The time frame was chosen due to the existence of an editorial standard in relation to the identity of the young woman: the analyzed editions show the concern with a given authenticity of the reader, through the slogan “be different, be you”. Also, Capricho magazine is understood as a historical source used in a school context. Supported by references from the field of History and Communication, it is understood the relationship between Capricho and readers in its complexity, both build each other recursively, they are interdependent. From this idea, it is possible to think and problematize not only the media as a producer of gender pedagogies, but also the public as a co-producer of the magazine, since it appropriates its cultural codes, in order not to clash with the horizon. expectations of your readers. Finally, it is based on references from the investigative field of Historical Education, where it seeks to investigate, also, how the historical learning of the subjects takes place. Still, the concept of “historical literacy” coined by Peter Lee is used, in an analysis of students' speeches about gender and sexuality issues at Capricho. It was noticed that students already bring ideas and notions about gender and that such ideas reproduce, to a certain extent, a conservative conception. However, they demonstrate the ability to observe and historicize the gender issues that Capricho brings, reading it as a historical source, that is, contextualizing their discourses, which means a “historical literacy”.
publishDate 2014
dc.date.none.fl_str_mv 2014-12-19
dc.type.driver.fl_str_mv info:eu-repo/semantics/article
info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
format article
status_str publishedVersion
dc.identifier.uri.fl_str_mv https://ojs.uel.br/revistas/uel/index.php/antiteses/article/view/20554
10.5433/1984-3356.2014v7n14p534
url https://ojs.uel.br/revistas/uel/index.php/antiteses/article/view/20554
identifier_str_mv 10.5433/1984-3356.2014v7n14p534
dc.language.iso.fl_str_mv por
language por
dc.relation.none.fl_str_mv https://ojs.uel.br/revistas/uel/index.php/antiteses/article/view/20554/15641
dc.rights.driver.fl_str_mv Copyright (c) 2014 Antíteses
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0
info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
rights_invalid_str_mv Copyright (c) 2014 Antíteses
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0
eu_rights_str_mv openAccess
dc.format.none.fl_str_mv application/pdf
dc.publisher.none.fl_str_mv Universidade Estadual de Londrina
publisher.none.fl_str_mv Universidade Estadual de Londrina
dc.source.none.fl_str_mv Antíteses; Vol. 7 No. 14 (2014): Histórias e Antropologias dos Patrimônios Culturais; 534-536
Antíteses; v. 7 n. 14 (2014): Histórias e Antropologias dos Patrimônios Culturais; 534-536
1984-3356
reponame:Antíteses
instname:Universidade Estadual de Londrina (UEL)
instacron:UEL
instname_str Universidade Estadual de Londrina (UEL)
instacron_str UEL
institution UEL
reponame_str Antíteses
collection Antíteses
repository.name.fl_str_mv Antíteses - Universidade Estadual de Londrina (UEL)
repository.mail.fl_str_mv antiteses@uel.br||
_version_ 1797069046559014912