Desenvolvimento das habilidades orais e escritas em lÃngua estrangeira pro professores de inglÃs em formaÃÃo nas modalidades presencial e à distÃncia

Detalhes bibliográficos
Autor(a) principal: JoÃo Tobias Lima Sales
Data de Publicação: 2015
Tipo de documento: Tese
Idioma: por
Título da fonte: Biblioteca Digital de Teses e Dissertações da UFC
Texto Completo: http://www.teses.ufc.br/tde_busca/arquivo.php?codArquivo=14136
Resumo: Based on the Theory of Information Processing, this longitudinal study compared the development of oral and written skills of students in ESL Teaching Certificate Programs in two different learning environments â distance learning and on-site learning. The quali-quantitative analysis of the studentsâ oral and written skills during four semesters aimed at determining if the prospective teachers, from the two different learning environments, developed oral and written skills at similar levels, and which learning environment proved more effective for developing one or another type of language skill. The participants were students from the first semester of two ESL Teaching Certificate Programs at the Federal University of Cearà - five students in the distance program and seven in the on-site program. The following three instruments were used to collect data from the participants during four semesters: a) a socio-economic questionnaire, which surveyed their educational, economic and social environment, as well as their language learning background; b) two complete TOEFL iBT tests, applied in the first and in the fourth semesters, as pre- and post-tests; and c) written and oral tasks in each of the four semesters, analyzed for: fluency (number of words divided by time), lexical and syntactic accuracy (wrong words divided by produced words and number of correct sentences divided by number of independent sentences, respectively), and lexical and syntactic complexity (number of different words divided by number of words produced and number of individual sentences divided by number of analysis units, respectively). Data were analyzed using ANOVA tests to investigate three variables: Group, Time and the Interaction between Group and Time. Results indicate that both groups developed listening, reading and writing skills at similar levels in a period of four-semesters. However, the on-site group developed oral production skills at a higher level than the distance learning group. As for fluency, accuracy and complexity, it was observed that the variable Time influenced the participants from the two groups in three parameters â fluency, sentence accuracy and sentence complexity. The variable Group had an effect on the same parameters, but with a significant difference for the on-site group. The interaction between Group and Time did not show any significance level that could account for the superiority of one learning environment over another in any of the three analyzed parameters. In the written tasks, the variable Time demonstrated significant development of all the participants in all the analyzed parameters. The variable Group had a significant positive effect on lexical and sentence accuracy for the on-site group. The interaction between Group and Time did not show any significant difference between the groups that could indicate that one learning environment is more effective than the other in the long run. Overall, the results of this research demystify the impossibility of learning a second language in a distance learning environment, since they indicate that both groups increased levels of language development.
id UFC_c9cf7084c56ffc0443a87d137bc039f2
oai_identifier_str oai:www.teses.ufc.br:9336
network_acronym_str UFC
network_name_str Biblioteca Digital de Teses e Dissertações da UFC
spelling info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersioninfo:eu-repo/semantics/doctoralThesisDesenvolvimento das habilidades orais e escritas em lÃngua estrangeira pro professores de inglÃs em formaÃÃo nas modalidades presencial e à distÃnciaOral and written skills development in foreign language by teachers of English in formation in face-to-face and distance learning2015-03-30VlÃdia Maria Cabral Borges12068012391Denise de Paula Martins de Abreu e Lima 12334564826http://lattes.cnpq.br/6212114975297800Rafael Vetromille de Castro 75513307049http://lattes.cnpq.br/3640307400529210Rozania Maria Alves de Moraes 32166826334Maria Elias Soares02178761372http://buscatextual.cnpq.br/buscatextual/busca.do69101523368http://lattes.cnpq.br/4020187414113280JoÃo Tobias Lima SalesUniversidade Federal do CearÃPrograma de PÃs-GraduaÃÃo em LingÃÃsticaUFCBRDistance language learning Oral and written skills Fluency, accuracy and complexityEnsino de idiomas a distÃncia Habilidades orais e escritas FluÃncia, acurÃcia, complexidadeLINGUAS ESTRANGEIRAS MODERNASBased on the Theory of Information Processing, this longitudinal study compared the development of oral and written skills of students in ESL Teaching Certificate Programs in two different learning environments â distance learning and on-site learning. The quali-quantitative analysis of the studentsâ oral and written skills during four semesters aimed at determining if the prospective teachers, from the two different learning environments, developed oral and written skills at similar levels, and which learning environment proved more effective for developing one or another type of language skill. The participants were students from the first semester of two ESL Teaching Certificate Programs at the Federal University of Cearà - five students in the distance program and seven in the on-site program. The following three instruments were used to collect data from the participants during four semesters: a) a socio-economic questionnaire, which surveyed their educational, economic and social environment, as well as their language learning background; b) two complete TOEFL iBT tests, applied in the first and in the fourth semesters, as pre- and post-tests; and c) written and oral tasks in each of the four semesters, analyzed for: fluency (number of words divided by time), lexical and syntactic accuracy (wrong words divided by produced words and number of correct sentences divided by number of independent sentences, respectively), and lexical and syntactic complexity (number of different words divided by number of words produced and number of individual sentences divided by number of analysis units, respectively). Data were analyzed using ANOVA tests to investigate three variables: Group, Time and the Interaction between Group and Time. Results indicate that both groups developed listening, reading and writing skills at similar levels in a period of four-semesters. However, the on-site group developed oral production skills at a higher level than the distance learning group. As for fluency, accuracy and complexity, it was observed that the variable Time influenced the participants from the two groups in three parameters â fluency, sentence accuracy and sentence complexity. The variable Group had an effect on the same parameters, but with a significant difference for the on-site group. The interaction between Group and Time did not show any significance level that could account for the superiority of one learning environment over another in any of the three analyzed parameters. In the written tasks, the variable Time demonstrated significant development of all the participants in all the analyzed parameters. The variable Group had a significant positive effect on lexical and sentence accuracy for the on-site group. The interaction between Group and Time did not show any significant difference between the groups that could indicate that one learning environment is more effective than the other in the long run. Overall, the results of this research demystify the impossibility of learning a second language in a distance learning environment, since they indicate that both groups increased levels of language development.Esta pesquisa longitudinal comparou o desenvolvimento das habilidades orais e escritas de professores de inglÃs em formaÃÃo nas modalidades presencial e a distÃncia, ao analisar a aprendizagem de inglÃs dos dois grupos a partir de da perspectiva da Teoria do Processamento da InformaÃÃo. A avaliaÃÃo qualiquantitativa das habilidades orais e escritas procurou verificar se futuros professores desenvolvem habilidades orais e escritas em nÃveis equivalentes e evidenciar a modalidade de ensino mais eficaz no desenvolvimento de uma ou outra habilidade no idioma. Alunos do primeiro semestre de dois cursos de Letras/InglÃs da Universidade Federal do Cearà participaram da pesquisa, sete alunos do curso noturno presencial, com sede em Fortaleza, e cinco alunos do curso a distÃncia, cujo polo de apoio alunos situa-se na cidade de Beberibe. Durante quatro semestres, os participantes foram submetidos a trÃs instrumentos de coleta de dados: a) um questionÃrio socioeconÃmico e educacional, que revelou a realidade social e educacional, assim como o conhecimento prÃvio de lÃngua inglesa dos participantes; b) dois testes TOEFL iBT, realizados como prÃ-teste, durante o primeiro semestre da graduaÃÃo, e como pÃs-teste no final do quarto semestre, que indicaram o nÃvel de proficiÃncia dos alunos no inÃcio da graduaÃÃo e no final do quarto semestre letivo; e c) atividades de produÃÃo oral e escrita, realizadas nos quatro semestres letivos e analisadas considerando-se trÃs parÃmetros: fluÃncia (palavras produzidas dividas pelo tempo), acurÃcia (lexical, palavras erradas divididas pelas palavras produzidas, e oracional, oraÃÃes corretas divididas pelas oraÃÃes independentes) e complexidade (lexical, quantidade de palavras diferentes dividida pelo nÃmero de palavras utilizadas no texto, e oracional, quantidade de oraÃÃes individuais dividida pela quantidade de unidades de anÃlise). Os dados foram analisados atravÃs de modelos de ANOVA, considerando o efeito das variÃveis grupo, tempo e interaÃÃo do grupo com o tempo. Concluiu-se que, em relaÃÃo Ãs habilidades de compreenssÃo auditiva e leitora e de produÃÃo escrita, ambos os grupos demonstraram nÃveis de desenvolvimento equivalentes no intervalo de quatro semestres. Contudo, na habilidade de produÃÃo oral, o grupo presencial apresentou desenvolvimento superior ao grupo a distÃncia. Sobre os parÃmetros de fluÃncia, acurÃcia e complexidade, percebeu-se que, oralmente, o fator Tempo influenciou todos os participantes nos parÃmetros: fluÃncia, acurÃcia oracional e complexidade oracional. O fator Grupo influenciou os mesmos parÃmetros, mas com diferenÃa significativa para o grupo presencial. O cruzamento dos fatores Grupo e Tempo nÃo revelou nÃvel de significÃncia que representasse destaque de uma modalidade sobre outra em oralidade em nenhum parÃmetro. Nas produÃÃes escritas, o fator Tempo apresentou desenvolvimento significativo de todos os participantes em todos os parÃmetros. O fator Grupo influenciou os parÃmetros: acurÃcia lexical e oracional, com diferenÃa significativa para o grupo presencial. O cruzamento dos fatores Grupo e Tempo nÃo revelou nÃvel de significÃncia que demonstrasse a prevalÃncia de uma modalidade de ensino sobre a outra. Esses resultados desmistificam a impossibilidade de aprender-se uma lÃngua estrangeira a distÃncia, pois retratam curvas de desenvolvimento de aprendizagem tanto para o grupo presencial como para o grupo a distÃncia.nÃo hÃhttp://www.teses.ufc.br/tde_busca/arquivo.php?codArquivo=14136application/pdfinfo:eu-repo/semantics/openAccessporreponame:Biblioteca Digital de Teses e Dissertações da UFCinstname:Universidade Federal do Cearáinstacron:UFC2019-01-21T11:27:21Zmail@mail.com -
dc.title.pt.fl_str_mv Desenvolvimento das habilidades orais e escritas em lÃngua estrangeira pro professores de inglÃs em formaÃÃo nas modalidades presencial e à distÃncia
dc.title.alternative..fl_str_mv Oral and written skills development in foreign language by teachers of English in formation in face-to-face and distance learning
title Desenvolvimento das habilidades orais e escritas em lÃngua estrangeira pro professores de inglÃs em formaÃÃo nas modalidades presencial e à distÃncia
spellingShingle Desenvolvimento das habilidades orais e escritas em lÃngua estrangeira pro professores de inglÃs em formaÃÃo nas modalidades presencial e à distÃncia
JoÃo Tobias Lima Sales
Ensino de idiomas a distÃncia
Habilidades orais e escritas
FluÃncia, acurÃcia, complexidade
LINGUAS ESTRANGEIRAS MODERNAS
title_short Desenvolvimento das habilidades orais e escritas em lÃngua estrangeira pro professores de inglÃs em formaÃÃo nas modalidades presencial e à distÃncia
title_full Desenvolvimento das habilidades orais e escritas em lÃngua estrangeira pro professores de inglÃs em formaÃÃo nas modalidades presencial e à distÃncia
title_fullStr Desenvolvimento das habilidades orais e escritas em lÃngua estrangeira pro professores de inglÃs em formaÃÃo nas modalidades presencial e à distÃncia
title_full_unstemmed Desenvolvimento das habilidades orais e escritas em lÃngua estrangeira pro professores de inglÃs em formaÃÃo nas modalidades presencial e à distÃncia
title_sort Desenvolvimento das habilidades orais e escritas em lÃngua estrangeira pro professores de inglÃs em formaÃÃo nas modalidades presencial e à distÃncia
author JoÃo Tobias Lima Sales
author_facet JoÃo Tobias Lima Sales
author_role author
dc.contributor.advisor1.fl_str_mv VlÃdia Maria Cabral Borges
dc.contributor.advisor1ID.fl_str_mv 12068012391
dc.contributor.referee1.fl_str_mv Denise de Paula Martins de Abreu e Lima
dc.contributor.referee1ID.fl_str_mv 12334564826
dc.contributor.referee1Lattes.fl_str_mv http://lattes.cnpq.br/6212114975297800
dc.contributor.referee2.fl_str_mv Rafael Vetromille de Castro
dc.contributor.referee2ID.fl_str_mv 75513307049
dc.contributor.referee2Lattes.fl_str_mv http://lattes.cnpq.br/3640307400529210
dc.contributor.referee3.fl_str_mv Rozania Maria Alves de Moraes
dc.contributor.referee3ID.fl_str_mv 32166826334
dc.contributor.referee4.fl_str_mv Maria Elias Soares
dc.contributor.referee4ID.fl_str_mv 02178761372
dc.contributor.referee4Lattes.fl_str_mv http://buscatextual.cnpq.br/buscatextual/busca.do
dc.contributor.authorID.fl_str_mv 69101523368
dc.contributor.authorLattes.fl_str_mv http://lattes.cnpq.br/4020187414113280
dc.contributor.author.fl_str_mv JoÃo Tobias Lima Sales
contributor_str_mv VlÃdia Maria Cabral Borges
Denise de Paula Martins de Abreu e Lima
Rafael Vetromille de Castro
Rozania Maria Alves de Moraes
Maria Elias Soares
dc.subject.por.fl_str_mv Ensino de idiomas a distÃncia
Habilidades orais e escritas
FluÃncia, acurÃcia, complexidade
topic Ensino de idiomas a distÃncia
Habilidades orais e escritas
FluÃncia, acurÃcia, complexidade
LINGUAS ESTRANGEIRAS MODERNAS
dc.subject.cnpq.fl_str_mv LINGUAS ESTRANGEIRAS MODERNAS
dc.description.sponsorship.fl_txt_mv nÃo hÃ
dc.description.abstract..fl_txt_mv Based on the Theory of Information Processing, this longitudinal study compared the development of oral and written skills of students in ESL Teaching Certificate Programs in two different learning environments â distance learning and on-site learning. The quali-quantitative analysis of the studentsâ oral and written skills during four semesters aimed at determining if the prospective teachers, from the two different learning environments, developed oral and written skills at similar levels, and which learning environment proved more effective for developing one or another type of language skill. The participants were students from the first semester of two ESL Teaching Certificate Programs at the Federal University of Cearà - five students in the distance program and seven in the on-site program. The following three instruments were used to collect data from the participants during four semesters: a) a socio-economic questionnaire, which surveyed their educational, economic and social environment, as well as their language learning background; b) two complete TOEFL iBT tests, applied in the first and in the fourth semesters, as pre- and post-tests; and c) written and oral tasks in each of the four semesters, analyzed for: fluency (number of words divided by time), lexical and syntactic accuracy (wrong words divided by produced words and number of correct sentences divided by number of independent sentences, respectively), and lexical and syntactic complexity (number of different words divided by number of words produced and number of individual sentences divided by number of analysis units, respectively). Data were analyzed using ANOVA tests to investigate three variables: Group, Time and the Interaction between Group and Time. Results indicate that both groups developed listening, reading and writing skills at similar levels in a period of four-semesters. However, the on-site group developed oral production skills at a higher level than the distance learning group. As for fluency, accuracy and complexity, it was observed that the variable Time influenced the participants from the two groups in three parameters â fluency, sentence accuracy and sentence complexity. The variable Group had an effect on the same parameters, but with a significant difference for the on-site group. The interaction between Group and Time did not show any significance level that could account for the superiority of one learning environment over another in any of the three analyzed parameters. In the written tasks, the variable Time demonstrated significant development of all the participants in all the analyzed parameters. The variable Group had a significant positive effect on lexical and sentence accuracy for the on-site group. The interaction between Group and Time did not show any significant difference between the groups that could indicate that one learning environment is more effective than the other in the long run. Overall, the results of this research demystify the impossibility of learning a second language in a distance learning environment, since they indicate that both groups increased levels of language development.
dc.description.abstract.por.fl_txt_mv Esta pesquisa longitudinal comparou o desenvolvimento das habilidades orais e escritas de professores de inglÃs em formaÃÃo nas modalidades presencial e a distÃncia, ao analisar a aprendizagem de inglÃs dos dois grupos a partir de da perspectiva da Teoria do Processamento da InformaÃÃo. A avaliaÃÃo qualiquantitativa das habilidades orais e escritas procurou verificar se futuros professores desenvolvem habilidades orais e escritas em nÃveis equivalentes e evidenciar a modalidade de ensino mais eficaz no desenvolvimento de uma ou outra habilidade no idioma. Alunos do primeiro semestre de dois cursos de Letras/InglÃs da Universidade Federal do Cearà participaram da pesquisa, sete alunos do curso noturno presencial, com sede em Fortaleza, e cinco alunos do curso a distÃncia, cujo polo de apoio alunos situa-se na cidade de Beberibe. Durante quatro semestres, os participantes foram submetidos a trÃs instrumentos de coleta de dados: a) um questionÃrio socioeconÃmico e educacional, que revelou a realidade social e educacional, assim como o conhecimento prÃvio de lÃngua inglesa dos participantes; b) dois testes TOEFL iBT, realizados como prÃ-teste, durante o primeiro semestre da graduaÃÃo, e como pÃs-teste no final do quarto semestre, que indicaram o nÃvel de proficiÃncia dos alunos no inÃcio da graduaÃÃo e no final do quarto semestre letivo; e c) atividades de produÃÃo oral e escrita, realizadas nos quatro semestres letivos e analisadas considerando-se trÃs parÃmetros: fluÃncia (palavras produzidas dividas pelo tempo), acurÃcia (lexical, palavras erradas divididas pelas palavras produzidas, e oracional, oraÃÃes corretas divididas pelas oraÃÃes independentes) e complexidade (lexical, quantidade de palavras diferentes dividida pelo nÃmero de palavras utilizadas no texto, e oracional, quantidade de oraÃÃes individuais dividida pela quantidade de unidades de anÃlise). Os dados foram analisados atravÃs de modelos de ANOVA, considerando o efeito das variÃveis grupo, tempo e interaÃÃo do grupo com o tempo. Concluiu-se que, em relaÃÃo Ãs habilidades de compreenssÃo auditiva e leitora e de produÃÃo escrita, ambos os grupos demonstraram nÃveis de desenvolvimento equivalentes no intervalo de quatro semestres. Contudo, na habilidade de produÃÃo oral, o grupo presencial apresentou desenvolvimento superior ao grupo a distÃncia. Sobre os parÃmetros de fluÃncia, acurÃcia e complexidade, percebeu-se que, oralmente, o fator Tempo influenciou todos os participantes nos parÃmetros: fluÃncia, acurÃcia oracional e complexidade oracional. O fator Grupo influenciou os mesmos parÃmetros, mas com diferenÃa significativa para o grupo presencial. O cruzamento dos fatores Grupo e Tempo nÃo revelou nÃvel de significÃncia que representasse destaque de uma modalidade sobre outra em oralidade em nenhum parÃmetro. Nas produÃÃes escritas, o fator Tempo apresentou desenvolvimento significativo de todos os participantes em todos os parÃmetros. O fator Grupo influenciou os parÃmetros: acurÃcia lexical e oracional, com diferenÃa significativa para o grupo presencial. O cruzamento dos fatores Grupo e Tempo nÃo revelou nÃvel de significÃncia que demonstrasse a prevalÃncia de uma modalidade de ensino sobre a outra. Esses resultados desmistificam a impossibilidade de aprender-se uma lÃngua estrangeira a distÃncia, pois retratam curvas de desenvolvimento de aprendizagem tanto para o grupo presencial como para o grupo a distÃncia.
description Based on the Theory of Information Processing, this longitudinal study compared the development of oral and written skills of students in ESL Teaching Certificate Programs in two different learning environments â distance learning and on-site learning. The quali-quantitative analysis of the studentsâ oral and written skills during four semesters aimed at determining if the prospective teachers, from the two different learning environments, developed oral and written skills at similar levels, and which learning environment proved more effective for developing one or another type of language skill. The participants were students from the first semester of two ESL Teaching Certificate Programs at the Federal University of Cearà - five students in the distance program and seven in the on-site program. The following three instruments were used to collect data from the participants during four semesters: a) a socio-economic questionnaire, which surveyed their educational, economic and social environment, as well as their language learning background; b) two complete TOEFL iBT tests, applied in the first and in the fourth semesters, as pre- and post-tests; and c) written and oral tasks in each of the four semesters, analyzed for: fluency (number of words divided by time), lexical and syntactic accuracy (wrong words divided by produced words and number of correct sentences divided by number of independent sentences, respectively), and lexical and syntactic complexity (number of different words divided by number of words produced and number of individual sentences divided by number of analysis units, respectively). Data were analyzed using ANOVA tests to investigate three variables: Group, Time and the Interaction between Group and Time. Results indicate that both groups developed listening, reading and writing skills at similar levels in a period of four-semesters. However, the on-site group developed oral production skills at a higher level than the distance learning group. As for fluency, accuracy and complexity, it was observed that the variable Time influenced the participants from the two groups in three parameters â fluency, sentence accuracy and sentence complexity. The variable Group had an effect on the same parameters, but with a significant difference for the on-site group. The interaction between Group and Time did not show any significance level that could account for the superiority of one learning environment over another in any of the three analyzed parameters. In the written tasks, the variable Time demonstrated significant development of all the participants in all the analyzed parameters. The variable Group had a significant positive effect on lexical and sentence accuracy for the on-site group. The interaction between Group and Time did not show any significant difference between the groups that could indicate that one learning environment is more effective than the other in the long run. Overall, the results of this research demystify the impossibility of learning a second language in a distance learning environment, since they indicate that both groups increased levels of language development.
publishDate 2015
dc.date.issued.fl_str_mv 2015-03-30
dc.type.status.fl_str_mv info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
dc.type.driver.fl_str_mv info:eu-repo/semantics/doctoralThesis
status_str publishedVersion
format doctoralThesis
dc.identifier.uri.fl_str_mv http://www.teses.ufc.br/tde_busca/arquivo.php?codArquivo=14136
url http://www.teses.ufc.br/tde_busca/arquivo.php?codArquivo=14136
dc.language.iso.fl_str_mv por
language por
dc.rights.driver.fl_str_mv info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
eu_rights_str_mv openAccess
dc.format.none.fl_str_mv application/pdf
dc.publisher.none.fl_str_mv Universidade Federal do CearÃ
dc.publisher.program.fl_str_mv Programa de PÃs-GraduaÃÃo em LingÃÃstica
dc.publisher.initials.fl_str_mv UFC
dc.publisher.country.fl_str_mv BR
publisher.none.fl_str_mv Universidade Federal do CearÃ
dc.source.none.fl_str_mv reponame:Biblioteca Digital de Teses e Dissertações da UFC
instname:Universidade Federal do Ceará
instacron:UFC
reponame_str Biblioteca Digital de Teses e Dissertações da UFC
collection Biblioteca Digital de Teses e Dissertações da UFC
instname_str Universidade Federal do Ceará
instacron_str UFC
institution UFC
repository.name.fl_str_mv -
repository.mail.fl_str_mv mail@mail.com
_version_ 1643295203292872704