MILITARY ELITES, TRAJECTORIES AND POLITICAL-INSTITUTIONAL REDEFINITIONS (1850-1930)

Detalhes bibliográficos
Autor(a) principal: Seidl, Ernesto
Data de Publicação: 2008
Tipo de documento: Artigo
Idioma: por
Título da fonte: Revista de Sociologia e Política
Texto Completo: https://revistas.ufpr.br/rsp/article/view/13861
Resumo: This study looks at the social and cultural conditions of the formation of the Brazilian army duringthe Empire and the First Republic. Within a context of weak military autonomy vis-a-vis other socialspheres, our results point to the functioning of hybrid recruitment and selection mechanisms regulatedby contradictory logics that fuse meritocratic principles (academic degrees, years of service, courage)and extra-meritocratic ones (personalist relationships, political notoreity) for the purposes of promotion.Without denying the effects of the expansion of the military school system and the adoption offormal regulation criteria, our study aims to explore the objective impacts of such innovation overthat professional sphere, permitting the analysis of the varied types of resources and strategiesemployed by social agents, in particular the use of relationships based on personal reciprocity andtaking political positions. The reconstitution of the Brazilian military space through the examinationof the trajectories of high level officials seeks to contribute to an understanding of what conceptionsagents present as legitimate or illegitimate, with conducts being read in variable ways according tothe viewpoint adopted and the position occupied within social space. Through an in-depth presentationof two particular trajectories, we note how relationships between social practices, conceptions andmeanings associated with particular agents and groups and the processes of institutional re-definitionthey are located within are articulated, seeking to shed new light on the question of the transformationof political space and the processes of institutional innovation underway in Brazil during the period.
id UFPR-10_8fff205c7184c0dc51e872bfdf7b5f3d
oai_identifier_str oai:revistas.ufpr.br:article/13861
network_acronym_str UFPR-10
network_name_str Revista de Sociologia e Política
repository_id_str
spelling MILITARY ELITES, TRAJECTORIES AND POLITICAL-INSTITUTIONAL REDEFINITIONS (1850-1930)ÉLITES MILITAIRES, TRAJECTOIRES ET REDÉFINITIONS POLITICOINSTITUTIONNELLES (1850-1930)ELITES MILITARES, TRAJETÓRIAS E REDEFINIÇÕES POLÍTICO-INSTITUCIONAIS (1850-1930)elites militares; Exército; meritocracia; clientelismo; trajetórias sociais; military elite; Army; meritocracy; clientelism; social trajectories; élites militaires ; Armée ; méritocratie ; clientélisme politique ; trajectoires socialesThis study looks at the social and cultural conditions of the formation of the Brazilian army duringthe Empire and the First Republic. Within a context of weak military autonomy vis-a-vis other socialspheres, our results point to the functioning of hybrid recruitment and selection mechanisms regulatedby contradictory logics that fuse meritocratic principles (academic degrees, years of service, courage)and extra-meritocratic ones (personalist relationships, political notoreity) for the purposes of promotion.Without denying the effects of the expansion of the military school system and the adoption offormal regulation criteria, our study aims to explore the objective impacts of such innovation overthat professional sphere, permitting the analysis of the varied types of resources and strategiesemployed by social agents, in particular the use of relationships based on personal reciprocity andtaking political positions. The reconstitution of the Brazilian military space through the examinationof the trajectories of high level officials seeks to contribute to an understanding of what conceptionsagents present as legitimate or illegitimate, with conducts being read in variable ways according tothe viewpoint adopted and the position occupied within social space. Through an in-depth presentationof two particular trajectories, we note how relationships between social practices, conceptions andmeanings associated with particular agents and groups and the processes of institutional re-definitionthey are located within are articulated, seeking to shed new light on the question of the transformationof political space and the processes of institutional innovation underway in Brazil during the period.L’étude examine les conditions sociales et culturelles de la formation de l’élite de l’Armée brésilienneentre l’Empire et la Première République. Dans un contexte d’autonomie réduite du militaire àl’égard des sphères sociales, les résultats indiquent un fonctionnement des mécanismes hybrides derecrutement et de sélection réglés par des logiques contradictoires intégrant des principesméritocratiques (titres scolaires, temps de travail, hardiesse) et extra-méritocratiques (relationspersonnelles, renommée politique) en vue de l’ascension dans la carrière. Sans méconnaitre leseffets de l’expansion du système scolaire militaire et l’adoption de critères formels de reglémentation,l’étude a essayé d’exploiter les impacts objectifs de telles innovations sur la sphère professionnellece qui rend possible l’analyse des combinaisons variées de recours et de stratégies mises en marchepar les agents sociaux, surtout l’emploi de relations basées dans la réciprocité personnelle et lesprises de position politique. La reconstituition de l’espace militaire brésilien à partir de l’examen destrajectoires de hauts officiers cherche à contribuer à la compréhension des conceptions que lesagents présentent comme légitime ou illégitime, les comportements étant lus de manière variableselon le point de vue adopté et la position occupée dans l’espace social. Au moyen d’une présentationen profondeur de deux trajectoires, on montre comment s’articulent les relations entre pratiquessociales, conceptions et significations associées à certains agents et groupes et les processus deredéfinition institutionnelle dans lesquels ils sont inserés, tout en cherchant à apporter une nouvellelumière aux transformations de l’espace politique et les processus de l’innovation institutionnelle encours au Brésil de cette période.O estudo aborda as condições sociais e culturais de formação da elite do Exército brasileiro entre o Impérioe a Primeira República. Em um contexto de baixa autonomia do domínio militar frente a outras esferassociais, os resultados apontam para o funcionamento de mecanismos híbridos de recrutamento e seleçãoregulados por lógicas contraditórias que fundem princípios meritocráticos (títulos escolares, tempo deserviço, bravura) e extra-meritocráticos (relações personalísticas, notoriedade política) para a ascensãona carreira. Sem desconhecer os efeitos da expansão do sistema escolar militar e a adoção de critériosformais de regulação, o estudo procurou explorar os impactos objetivos de tais inovações sobre aquelaesfera profissional dando espaço para a análise das variadas combinações de recursos e estratégias acionadospelos agentes sociais, em especial o uso de relações baseadas na reciprocidade pessoal e as tomadasde posição política. A reconstituição do espaço militar brasileiro a partir do exame das trajetórias de altosoficiais procura contribuir para a compreensão das concepções que os agentes apresentam como legítimoou ilegítimo, as condutas sendo lidas de modo variável segundo o ponto de vista adotado e a posiçãoocupada no espaço social. Por meio da apresentação em profundidade de duas trajetórias, aponta-se comose articulam as relações entre práticas sociais, concepções e significados associados a determinados agentese grupos e os processos de redefinição institucional em que estão inseridos, buscando trazer nova luzsobre as transformações do espaço político e os processos de inovação institucional em curso no Brasil doperíodo.UFPR2008-06-30info:eu-repo/semantics/articleinfo:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersionapplication/pdfhttps://revistas.ufpr.br/rsp/article/view/13861Revista de Sociologia e Política; v. 16, n. 30 (2008)1678-98730104-4478reponame:Revista de Sociologia e Políticainstname:Universidade Federal do Paraná (UFPR)instacron:UFPRporhttps://revistas.ufpr.br/rsp/article/view/13861/9335Seidl, Ernestoinfo:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess2009-04-08T16:26:08Zoai:revistas.ufpr.br:article/13861Revistahttps://revistas.ufpr.br/rspPUBhttps://revistas.ufpr.br/rsp/oai||editoriarsp@ufpr.br1678-98730104-4478opendoar:2009-04-08T16:26:08Revista de Sociologia e Política - Universidade Federal do Paraná (UFPR)false
dc.title.none.fl_str_mv MILITARY ELITES, TRAJECTORIES AND POLITICAL-INSTITUTIONAL REDEFINITIONS (1850-1930)
ÉLITES MILITAIRES, TRAJECTOIRES ET REDÉFINITIONS POLITICOINSTITUTIONNELLES (1850-1930)
ELITES MILITARES, TRAJETÓRIAS E REDEFINIÇÕES POLÍTICO-INSTITUCIONAIS (1850-1930)
title MILITARY ELITES, TRAJECTORIES AND POLITICAL-INSTITUTIONAL REDEFINITIONS (1850-1930)
spellingShingle MILITARY ELITES, TRAJECTORIES AND POLITICAL-INSTITUTIONAL REDEFINITIONS (1850-1930)
Seidl, Ernesto
elites militares; Exército; meritocracia; clientelismo; trajetórias sociais; military elite; Army; meritocracy; clientelism; social trajectories; élites militaires ; Armée ; méritocratie ; clientélisme politique ; trajectoires sociales
title_short MILITARY ELITES, TRAJECTORIES AND POLITICAL-INSTITUTIONAL REDEFINITIONS (1850-1930)
title_full MILITARY ELITES, TRAJECTORIES AND POLITICAL-INSTITUTIONAL REDEFINITIONS (1850-1930)
title_fullStr MILITARY ELITES, TRAJECTORIES AND POLITICAL-INSTITUTIONAL REDEFINITIONS (1850-1930)
title_full_unstemmed MILITARY ELITES, TRAJECTORIES AND POLITICAL-INSTITUTIONAL REDEFINITIONS (1850-1930)
title_sort MILITARY ELITES, TRAJECTORIES AND POLITICAL-INSTITUTIONAL REDEFINITIONS (1850-1930)
author Seidl, Ernesto
author_facet Seidl, Ernesto
author_role author
dc.contributor.author.fl_str_mv Seidl, Ernesto
dc.subject.por.fl_str_mv elites militares; Exército; meritocracia; clientelismo; trajetórias sociais; military elite; Army; meritocracy; clientelism; social trajectories; élites militaires ; Armée ; méritocratie ; clientélisme politique ; trajectoires sociales
topic elites militares; Exército; meritocracia; clientelismo; trajetórias sociais; military elite; Army; meritocracy; clientelism; social trajectories; élites militaires ; Armée ; méritocratie ; clientélisme politique ; trajectoires sociales
description This study looks at the social and cultural conditions of the formation of the Brazilian army duringthe Empire and the First Republic. Within a context of weak military autonomy vis-a-vis other socialspheres, our results point to the functioning of hybrid recruitment and selection mechanisms regulatedby contradictory logics that fuse meritocratic principles (academic degrees, years of service, courage)and extra-meritocratic ones (personalist relationships, political notoreity) for the purposes of promotion.Without denying the effects of the expansion of the military school system and the adoption offormal regulation criteria, our study aims to explore the objective impacts of such innovation overthat professional sphere, permitting the analysis of the varied types of resources and strategiesemployed by social agents, in particular the use of relationships based on personal reciprocity andtaking political positions. The reconstitution of the Brazilian military space through the examinationof the trajectories of high level officials seeks to contribute to an understanding of what conceptionsagents present as legitimate or illegitimate, with conducts being read in variable ways according tothe viewpoint adopted and the position occupied within social space. Through an in-depth presentationof two particular trajectories, we note how relationships between social practices, conceptions andmeanings associated with particular agents and groups and the processes of institutional re-definitionthey are located within are articulated, seeking to shed new light on the question of the transformationof political space and the processes of institutional innovation underway in Brazil during the period.
publishDate 2008
dc.date.none.fl_str_mv 2008-06-30
dc.type.none.fl_str_mv
dc.type.driver.fl_str_mv info:eu-repo/semantics/article
info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
format article
status_str publishedVersion
dc.identifier.uri.fl_str_mv https://revistas.ufpr.br/rsp/article/view/13861
url https://revistas.ufpr.br/rsp/article/view/13861
dc.language.iso.fl_str_mv por
language por
dc.relation.none.fl_str_mv https://revistas.ufpr.br/rsp/article/view/13861/9335
dc.rights.driver.fl_str_mv info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
eu_rights_str_mv openAccess
dc.format.none.fl_str_mv application/pdf
dc.publisher.none.fl_str_mv UFPR
publisher.none.fl_str_mv UFPR
dc.source.none.fl_str_mv Revista de Sociologia e Política; v. 16, n. 30 (2008)
1678-9873
0104-4478
reponame:Revista de Sociologia e Política
instname:Universidade Federal do Paraná (UFPR)
instacron:UFPR
instname_str Universidade Federal do Paraná (UFPR)
instacron_str UFPR
institution UFPR
reponame_str Revista de Sociologia e Política
collection Revista de Sociologia e Política
repository.name.fl_str_mv Revista de Sociologia e Política - Universidade Federal do Paraná (UFPR)
repository.mail.fl_str_mv ||editoriarsp@ufpr.br
_version_ 1799761025058209792