From forgetfulness to the deindexation: the internacional development of the controversy about the right to be forgotten e and the limitation of brazilian jurisprudence

Detalhes bibliográficos
Autor(a) principal: Vieira, José Ribas
Data de Publicação: 2019
Outros Autores: Andrade, Mário Cesar da Silva, Vasconcelos, Vitor Jorge Gonçalves
Tipo de documento: Artigo
Idioma: por
Título da fonte: Revista Espaço Jurídico/Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law
Texto Completo: https://periodicos.unoesc.edu.br/espacojuridico/article/view/20099
Resumo: The present essay analyses the development of the right to be forgotten starting from paradigmatic judgments, foreigners and nationals in kind, especially, on the recognition of the called right to be deindexed. Adopting as our underlying theme the jurisprudence in what concerns Lebach´s case, which took place in Germany, as well as Mario Costeja González v. Google, which occued in Spain, we seek to analyse critically how has been developed the brazilian jurisprudence regarding the right to be forgotten, through the understanding that was established by the Brazilian Court in the matter of the Aída Curi´s case, along with it´s revisions and limitations. Concerning the method, this research is qualitative, comprehensive and critical-reflexive in nature, adopting academic sources such as jurisprudence, with emphasis for the Brazilian Suprme Court of Justice´s decisions related to the right to be forgotten. As theoretical framework, were adopted a serie of doctrinial reflexions, especially, the opinion of Jorge Manrique, Stefano Rodotà and Francisco Javier Leturia Infant. In conclusion, it is shown how the brazilian jurisprudence has not still absorbed completely the right to be forgotten. Despite the fact that the brazilian jurisprudence has already approved the tecnical strategy of the deindexation, has not still progressed in what concerns the material dimension, that is, on the clarification of the contents which can limit viewers. Overcoming this challenge may be the brazilian contribution to the international development regarding a new perspective to the controversy of the right to be forgotten.
id UNOESC-1_6493a694e5611b8004d097df2766d7e4
oai_identifier_str oai:ojs.periodicos.unoesc.edu.br:article/20099
network_acronym_str UNOESC-1
network_name_str Revista Espaço Jurídico/Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law
repository_id_str
spelling From forgetfulness to the deindexation: the internacional development of the controversy about the right to be forgotten e and the limitation of brazilian jurisprudenceDo esquecimento à desindexação: a evolução internacional da controvérsia sobre o direito ao esquecimento e as limitações da jurisprudência brasileiraRight to be forgottenRight to be deindexedFundamental rightsBrazilian Suprme Court of JusticeDireito ao esquecimentoDireito à desindexaçãoDireitos fundamentaisSuperior Tribunal de JustiçaThe present essay analyses the development of the right to be forgotten starting from paradigmatic judgments, foreigners and nationals in kind, especially, on the recognition of the called right to be deindexed. Adopting as our underlying theme the jurisprudence in what concerns Lebach´s case, which took place in Germany, as well as Mario Costeja González v. Google, which occued in Spain, we seek to analyse critically how has been developed the brazilian jurisprudence regarding the right to be forgotten, through the understanding that was established by the Brazilian Court in the matter of the Aída Curi´s case, along with it´s revisions and limitations. Concerning the method, this research is qualitative, comprehensive and critical-reflexive in nature, adopting academic sources such as jurisprudence, with emphasis for the Brazilian Suprme Court of Justice´s decisions related to the right to be forgotten. As theoretical framework, were adopted a serie of doctrinial reflexions, especially, the opinion of Jorge Manrique, Stefano Rodotà and Francisco Javier Leturia Infant. In conclusion, it is shown how the brazilian jurisprudence has not still absorbed completely the right to be forgotten. Despite the fact that the brazilian jurisprudence has already approved the tecnical strategy of the deindexation, has not still progressed in what concerns the material dimension, that is, on the clarification of the contents which can limit viewers. Overcoming this challenge may be the brazilian contribution to the international development regarding a new perspective to the controversy of the right to be forgotten.O presente artigo analisa a evolução do direito ao esquecimento a partir de julgamentos paradigmáticos, estrangeiros e nacionais, especialmente, no reconhecimento do chamado direito à desindexação. Com esse novo direito supera-se algumas das dificuldades práticas em impedir a veiculação midiática de conteúdo ofensivo na internet. Adotando como fio condutor os julgamentos dos casos Lebach, ocorrido na Alemanha, e Mario Costeja González v. Google, ocorrido na Espanha, busca-se analisar criticamente a formação do entendimento jurisprudencial brasileiro sobre o direito ao esquecimento, a partir do entendimento firmado no julgamento do caso Aída Curi pelo Superior Tribunal de Justiça, bem como de suas revisões e limitações. Metodologicamente, a pesquisa qualitativa, de viés compreensivo e crítico-reflexivo, vale-se de fontes doutrinárias, legislativas e jurisprudenciais, com destaque para as decisões do Superior Tribunal de Justiça envolvendo o direito ao esquecimento. Como referencial teórico, são adotadas as reflexões doutrinárias sobre o direito ao esquecimento, especialmente, nas formulações de Jorge Manrique, Stefano Rodotà e Francisco Javier Leturia Infante. Em conclusão, aponta-se como a jurisprudência brasileira ainda não assimilou plenamente o direito à desindexação. Apesar de já ter reconhecido a estratégia técnica da desindexação, ainda não avançou na sua dimensão material, no esclarecimento dos conteúdos que fazem jus à restrição dos buscadores. Enfrentar esse desafio pode ser o contributo brasileiro à evolução internacional do direito ao esquecimento em novos termos.Universidade do Oeste de Santa Catarina, UNOESC2019-12-12info:eu-repo/semantics/articleinfo:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersionAvaliado por Paresapplication/pdftext/htmlhttps://periodicos.unoesc.edu.br/espacojuridico/article/view/2009910.18593/ejjl.20099Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law [EJJL]; Bd. 20 Nr. 2 (2019): Espaço Juridico Journal of Law [EJJL]; 397-418Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law [EJJL]; Vol. 20 No. 2 (2019): Espaço Juridico Journal of Law [EJJL]; 397-418Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law [EJJL]; Vol. 20 Núm. 2 (2019): Espaço Juridico Journal of Law [EJJL]; 397-418Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law [EJJL]; Vol. 20 No. 2 (2019): Espaço Juridico Journal of Law [EJJL]; 397-418Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law [EJJL]; v. 20 n. 2 (2019): Espaço Juridico Journal of Law [EJJL]; 397-4182179-79431519-5899reponame:Revista Espaço Jurídico/Espaço Jurídico Journal of Lawinstname:Universidade do Oeste de Santa Catarina (UNOESC)instacron:UNOESCporhttps://periodicos.unoesc.edu.br/espacojuridico/article/view/20099/13511https://periodicos.unoesc.edu.br/espacojuridico/article/view/20099/14070Copyright (c) 2019 José Ribas Vieira, Mário Cesar da Silva Andrade, Vitor Jorge Vitor Gonçalves Vasconcelosinfo:eu-repo/semantics/openAccessVieira, José RibasAndrade, Mário Cesar da SilvaVasconcelos, Vitor Jorge Gonçalves2020-10-16T20:18:55Zoai:ojs.periodicos.unoesc.edu.br:article/20099Revistahttps://portalperiodicos.unoesc.edu.br/espacojuridico/indexhttp://editora.unoesc.edu.br/index.php/espacojuridico/oaieditora@unoesc.edu.br||ejjl@unoesc.edu.br2179-79431519-5899opendoar:2020-10-16T20:18:55Revista Espaço Jurídico/Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law - Universidade do Oeste de Santa Catarina (UNOESC)false
dc.title.none.fl_str_mv From forgetfulness to the deindexation: the internacional development of the controversy about the right to be forgotten e and the limitation of brazilian jurisprudence
Do esquecimento à desindexação: a evolução internacional da controvérsia sobre o direito ao esquecimento e as limitações da jurisprudência brasileira
title From forgetfulness to the deindexation: the internacional development of the controversy about the right to be forgotten e and the limitation of brazilian jurisprudence
spellingShingle From forgetfulness to the deindexation: the internacional development of the controversy about the right to be forgotten e and the limitation of brazilian jurisprudence
Vieira, José Ribas
Right to be forgotten
Right to be deindexed
Fundamental rights
Brazilian Suprme Court of Justice
Direito ao esquecimento
Direito à desindexação
Direitos fundamentais
Superior Tribunal de Justiça
title_short From forgetfulness to the deindexation: the internacional development of the controversy about the right to be forgotten e and the limitation of brazilian jurisprudence
title_full From forgetfulness to the deindexation: the internacional development of the controversy about the right to be forgotten e and the limitation of brazilian jurisprudence
title_fullStr From forgetfulness to the deindexation: the internacional development of the controversy about the right to be forgotten e and the limitation of brazilian jurisprudence
title_full_unstemmed From forgetfulness to the deindexation: the internacional development of the controversy about the right to be forgotten e and the limitation of brazilian jurisprudence
title_sort From forgetfulness to the deindexation: the internacional development of the controversy about the right to be forgotten e and the limitation of brazilian jurisprudence
author Vieira, José Ribas
author_facet Vieira, José Ribas
Andrade, Mário Cesar da Silva
Vasconcelos, Vitor Jorge Gonçalves
author_role author
author2 Andrade, Mário Cesar da Silva
Vasconcelos, Vitor Jorge Gonçalves
author2_role author
author
dc.contributor.author.fl_str_mv Vieira, José Ribas
Andrade, Mário Cesar da Silva
Vasconcelos, Vitor Jorge Gonçalves
dc.subject.por.fl_str_mv Right to be forgotten
Right to be deindexed
Fundamental rights
Brazilian Suprme Court of Justice
Direito ao esquecimento
Direito à desindexação
Direitos fundamentais
Superior Tribunal de Justiça
topic Right to be forgotten
Right to be deindexed
Fundamental rights
Brazilian Suprme Court of Justice
Direito ao esquecimento
Direito à desindexação
Direitos fundamentais
Superior Tribunal de Justiça
description The present essay analyses the development of the right to be forgotten starting from paradigmatic judgments, foreigners and nationals in kind, especially, on the recognition of the called right to be deindexed. Adopting as our underlying theme the jurisprudence in what concerns Lebach´s case, which took place in Germany, as well as Mario Costeja González v. Google, which occued in Spain, we seek to analyse critically how has been developed the brazilian jurisprudence regarding the right to be forgotten, through the understanding that was established by the Brazilian Court in the matter of the Aída Curi´s case, along with it´s revisions and limitations. Concerning the method, this research is qualitative, comprehensive and critical-reflexive in nature, adopting academic sources such as jurisprudence, with emphasis for the Brazilian Suprme Court of Justice´s decisions related to the right to be forgotten. As theoretical framework, were adopted a serie of doctrinial reflexions, especially, the opinion of Jorge Manrique, Stefano Rodotà and Francisco Javier Leturia Infant. In conclusion, it is shown how the brazilian jurisprudence has not still absorbed completely the right to be forgotten. Despite the fact that the brazilian jurisprudence has already approved the tecnical strategy of the deindexation, has not still progressed in what concerns the material dimension, that is, on the clarification of the contents which can limit viewers. Overcoming this challenge may be the brazilian contribution to the international development regarding a new perspective to the controversy of the right to be forgotten.
publishDate 2019
dc.date.none.fl_str_mv 2019-12-12
dc.type.driver.fl_str_mv info:eu-repo/semantics/article
info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Avaliado por Pares
format article
status_str publishedVersion
dc.identifier.uri.fl_str_mv https://periodicos.unoesc.edu.br/espacojuridico/article/view/20099
10.18593/ejjl.20099
url https://periodicos.unoesc.edu.br/espacojuridico/article/view/20099
identifier_str_mv 10.18593/ejjl.20099
dc.language.iso.fl_str_mv por
language por
dc.relation.none.fl_str_mv https://periodicos.unoesc.edu.br/espacojuridico/article/view/20099/13511
https://periodicos.unoesc.edu.br/espacojuridico/article/view/20099/14070
dc.rights.driver.fl_str_mv info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
eu_rights_str_mv openAccess
dc.format.none.fl_str_mv application/pdf
text/html
dc.publisher.none.fl_str_mv Universidade do Oeste de Santa Catarina, UNOESC
publisher.none.fl_str_mv Universidade do Oeste de Santa Catarina, UNOESC
dc.source.none.fl_str_mv Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law [EJJL]; Bd. 20 Nr. 2 (2019): Espaço Juridico Journal of Law [EJJL]; 397-418
Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law [EJJL]; Vol. 20 No. 2 (2019): Espaço Juridico Journal of Law [EJJL]; 397-418
Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law [EJJL]; Vol. 20 Núm. 2 (2019): Espaço Juridico Journal of Law [EJJL]; 397-418
Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law [EJJL]; Vol. 20 No. 2 (2019): Espaço Juridico Journal of Law [EJJL]; 397-418
Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law [EJJL]; v. 20 n. 2 (2019): Espaço Juridico Journal of Law [EJJL]; 397-418
2179-7943
1519-5899
reponame:Revista Espaço Jurídico/Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law
instname:Universidade do Oeste de Santa Catarina (UNOESC)
instacron:UNOESC
instname_str Universidade do Oeste de Santa Catarina (UNOESC)
instacron_str UNOESC
institution UNOESC
reponame_str Revista Espaço Jurídico/Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law
collection Revista Espaço Jurídico/Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law
repository.name.fl_str_mv Revista Espaço Jurídico/Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law - Universidade do Oeste de Santa Catarina (UNOESC)
repository.mail.fl_str_mv editora@unoesc.edu.br||ejjl@unoesc.edu.br
_version_ 1814256229942296576