Is the Sophist a correction of the Republic? Plato and the problem of the “being” of the Ideas

Detalhes bibliográficos
Autor(a) principal: Braga da Silva, Andre Luiz
Data de Publicação: 2022
Tipo de documento: Artigo
Idioma: por
Título da fonte: Hypnos
Texto Completo: https://hypnos.org.br/index.php/hypnos/article/view/660
Resumo: Although the Sophist is the work that most explores the interrelationships between the Forms, it is possible to see in the Republic the affirmation of the existence of a “community of Ideas among themselves” (476a6-7). An example of this interrelation is presented in the Idea of the Good that causes the “being” of the other Ideas (509b7-8). It is noteworthy that this statement is revised in the Sophist, where this same “being” of the Ideas is explained by another cause, the Idea of Being (256a et passim). To evaluate the presence or not of this “revision”, this article will pursue the answer to three questions: (i) whether the predicate caused by the Good in the Republic has the same meaning as that caused by the Idea of Being in the Sophist; (ii) whether it is possible to establish a working rule for the causation of predicates within the so-called Theory of Ideas; (iii) whether Plato is correcting his Ontology in the Sophist.
id FSB_00bd15d265c5011123718bbdb6903119
oai_identifier_str oai:ojs.hypnos.org.br:article/660
network_acronym_str FSB
network_name_str Hypnos
repository_id_str
spelling Is the Sophist a correction of the Republic? Plato and the problem of the “being” of the IdeasSeria o Sofista uma correção da República? Platão e a questão do “ser” das IdeiasPlatoIdeaBeingOntologySophistRepublicIdeiaSerSofistaRepúblicaAlthough the Sophist is the work that most explores the interrelationships between the Forms, it is possible to see in the Republic the affirmation of the existence of a “community of Ideas among themselves” (476a6-7). An example of this interrelation is presented in the Idea of the Good that causes the “being” of the other Ideas (509b7-8). It is noteworthy that this statement is revised in the Sophist, where this same “being” of the Ideas is explained by another cause, the Idea of Being (256a et passim). To evaluate the presence or not of this “revision”, this article will pursue the answer to three questions: (i) whether the predicate caused by the Good in the Republic has the same meaning as that caused by the Idea of Being in the Sophist; (ii) whether it is possible to establish a working rule for the causation of predicates within the so-called Theory of Ideas; (iii) whether Plato is correcting his Ontology in the Sophist.Embora o Sofista seja a obra que mais explore as interrelações entre as Formas, é possível ver na República a afirmação da existência de “comunidade das Ideias entre si” (476a6-7). A apresentação de um exemplo dessa interrelação é a Ideia de Bem que causaria o “ser” das outras Ideias (509b7-8). Chama a atenção o fato dessa afirmativa ser revista no Sofista, no qual este mesmo predicado das Ideias é explicado por outra causa: a Ideia de Ser (256a et passim). Para uma avaliação da ocorrência ou não desta “revisão”, o presente trabalho perseguirá a resposta a três perguntas: (i) se o predicado causado pelo Bem na República tem o mesmo significado que aquele causado pelo Ser no Sofista; (ii) se é possível estabelecer uma regra de funcionamento da causação dos predicados dentro da assim chamada Teoria das Ideias; (iii) se Platão está corrigindo sua Ontologia no Sofista.Revista HypnosHypnos Journal2022-10-28info:eu-repo/semantics/articleinfo:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersionapplication/pdfhttps://hypnos.org.br/index.php/hypnos/article/view/660Revista Hypnos; n. 49 (2022); 148-167Hypnos Journal; No. 49 (2022); 148-1672177-53461413-9138reponame:Hypnosinstname:Faculdade de São Bento (FSB)instacron:FSBporhttps://hypnos.org.br/index.php/hypnos/article/view/660/635Copyright (c) 2022 Revista Hypnoshttps://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccessBraga da Silva, Andre Luiz2022-10-29T01:08:29Zoai:ojs.hypnos.org.br:article/660Revistahttps://hypnos.org.br/index.php/hypnosPRIhttps://hypnos.org.br/index.php/hypnos/oairachelgazolla@gmail.com2177-53461413-9138opendoar:2023-01-13T09:47:11.419778Hypnos - Faculdade de São Bento (FSB)false
dc.title.none.fl_str_mv Is the Sophist a correction of the Republic? Plato and the problem of the “being” of the Ideas
Seria o Sofista uma correção da República? Platão e a questão do “ser” das Ideias
title Is the Sophist a correction of the Republic? Plato and the problem of the “being” of the Ideas
spellingShingle Is the Sophist a correction of the Republic? Plato and the problem of the “being” of the Ideas
Braga da Silva, Andre Luiz
Plato
Idea
Being
Ontology
Sophist
Republic
Ideia
Ser
Sofista
República
title_short Is the Sophist a correction of the Republic? Plato and the problem of the “being” of the Ideas
title_full Is the Sophist a correction of the Republic? Plato and the problem of the “being” of the Ideas
title_fullStr Is the Sophist a correction of the Republic? Plato and the problem of the “being” of the Ideas
title_full_unstemmed Is the Sophist a correction of the Republic? Plato and the problem of the “being” of the Ideas
title_sort Is the Sophist a correction of the Republic? Plato and the problem of the “being” of the Ideas
author Braga da Silva, Andre Luiz
author_facet Braga da Silva, Andre Luiz
author_role author
dc.contributor.author.fl_str_mv Braga da Silva, Andre Luiz
dc.subject.por.fl_str_mv Plato
Idea
Being
Ontology
Sophist
Republic
Ideia
Ser
Sofista
República
topic Plato
Idea
Being
Ontology
Sophist
Republic
Ideia
Ser
Sofista
República
description Although the Sophist is the work that most explores the interrelationships between the Forms, it is possible to see in the Republic the affirmation of the existence of a “community of Ideas among themselves” (476a6-7). An example of this interrelation is presented in the Idea of the Good that causes the “being” of the other Ideas (509b7-8). It is noteworthy that this statement is revised in the Sophist, where this same “being” of the Ideas is explained by another cause, the Idea of Being (256a et passim). To evaluate the presence or not of this “revision”, this article will pursue the answer to three questions: (i) whether the predicate caused by the Good in the Republic has the same meaning as that caused by the Idea of Being in the Sophist; (ii) whether it is possible to establish a working rule for the causation of predicates within the so-called Theory of Ideas; (iii) whether Plato is correcting his Ontology in the Sophist.
publishDate 2022
dc.date.none.fl_str_mv 2022-10-28
dc.type.driver.fl_str_mv info:eu-repo/semantics/article
info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
format article
status_str publishedVersion
dc.identifier.uri.fl_str_mv https://hypnos.org.br/index.php/hypnos/article/view/660
url https://hypnos.org.br/index.php/hypnos/article/view/660
dc.language.iso.fl_str_mv por
language por
dc.relation.none.fl_str_mv https://hypnos.org.br/index.php/hypnos/article/view/660/635
dc.rights.driver.fl_str_mv Copyright (c) 2022 Revista Hypnos
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0
info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
rights_invalid_str_mv Copyright (c) 2022 Revista Hypnos
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0
eu_rights_str_mv openAccess
dc.format.none.fl_str_mv application/pdf
dc.publisher.none.fl_str_mv Revista Hypnos
Hypnos Journal
publisher.none.fl_str_mv Revista Hypnos
Hypnos Journal
dc.source.none.fl_str_mv Revista Hypnos; n. 49 (2022); 148-167
Hypnos Journal; No. 49 (2022); 148-167
2177-5346
1413-9138
reponame:Hypnos
instname:Faculdade de São Bento (FSB)
instacron:FSB
instname_str Faculdade de São Bento (FSB)
instacron_str FSB
institution FSB
reponame_str Hypnos
collection Hypnos
repository.name.fl_str_mv Hypnos - Faculdade de São Bento (FSB)
repository.mail.fl_str_mv rachelgazolla@gmail.com
_version_ 1797051294047797248

Registros relacionados