Uma análise comparativa das propostas Beyond Budgeting e gestão econômica

• Autor(a) principal: Gimenez, Levi
• Data de Publicação: 2009
• Tipo de documento: Dissertação
• Idioma: por
• Título da fonte: Biblioteca Digital de Teses e Dissertações da PUC_SP
• Texto Completo: https://tede2.pucsp.br/handle/handle/1758
• topic: Gestão econômica; Modelo de gestão; Administracao; Contabilidade de custo; Orcamento; Beyond Budgeting; Economic management; Management model´s; CNPQ::CIENCIAS SOCIAIS APLICADAS::ADMINISTRACAO::CIENCIAS CONTABEIS

Organizations, and the decision process in particular, are affected by the new economy dynamics, making managers, academics and investors search for new management models. From the inconformity of the existing management models appeared the Economic Management and Beyond Budgeting, the first, aiming organizational efficacy throughout the economic result, using the modern budget and the latter, through a flexible management denominated radical decentralization (empowerment), without budgets, having decisions taken by front line managers and elaborating a Rolling Forecast for economic planning. The problematic of this article was to accomplish a comparison between both, having the target to establish their main differences, and to validate the research it was applied Content Analysis technique, categorizing important expressions like management process, aiming the understanding of the proposal of the models facing the challenges of reaching organizational result and efficacy. Managerial tools, to visualize the tools available to managers, enabling them accomplish their mission. Information systems and decentralization complement the categories. The association of the key-words to the categories made clear the preoccupation of the Economic Management in relation to the management process, once 55.4% of the key-words are included in this category, against 26.3% from Beyond Budgeting. The power of Beyond Budgeting resides in managerial tools from where emerges 63.5% against 38.4%. The information systems with 6.3% are more important to the Economic Management, whereas decentralization with 8.6% is superior in Beyond Budgeting. It was denoted that both make use of budget, although under different denominations and under the auspices of this technique Economic Management was presented as a deductive, normative and descriptive model, seeking to support managers in their decision process through a strong concept basis, and Beyond Budgeting, inductive, originated from an empiric basis, from a research in organizations, establish a set of leadership principles and adaptive management and consider them as universal