Substituição processual conglobante : novas observações sobre a substituição processual nos processos coletivos e a necessidade de controle judicial da legitimação adequada e da adequada representação

• Autor(a) principal: Guerra, Márcia Vitor de Magalhães e
• Data de Publicação: 2009
• Tipo de documento: Dissertação
• Idioma: por
• Título da fonte: Repositório Institucional da Universidade Federal do Espírito Santo (riUfes)
• Texto Completo: http://repositorio.ufes.br/handle/10/2691
• topic: Civil procedure; Colective actions; Legitimacy; Replacement processual; Adequacy of representation; Processo civil; Ações coletivas; Legitimidade; Substituição processual; Adequada representação; Direito Processual Civil; Processo civil; Ação coletiva (Processo civil); Legitimidade (Direito); Partes nas ações (Direito); 340

Presents a new perspective of the institute of the replacement procedure in collective processes, from the dynamic reality of the so-called civil procedure constitutional, sensitive to the influences of the tradition of common Law in its structure, and the formalism-value, understood as a new phase of the methodological process. In this context, organizes a new profile of procedural legitimacy, correlated with the content of our hybrid civil procedure and its consequences in the design of ontological institute. This new profile includes the adequate legitimacy and adequate representation as appropriate ways to overcome what, at first, was considered as a major revolution in procedural collective Brazilian procedural legitimacy, the legitimacy legal, ope legis. That is, initially set up a model in which the legitimate entities enjoy the presumption of adequate representation, based on a pre-established value of the legislature, with the characteristic of being a model of mixed public legitimacy (model state) and organizations (organizational model). The results show that this model is no longer maintains because of the new prospects, indicating that the model proposes in this research is more appropriate to scope of civil collective. Apply the control of the adequacy of representation, of course, implies other problems that are visualized from the moment that draws the profile of action of the main entities legitimized. The legitimacy on collective action is the subject that has evolved in a collective process and in the Brazilian law, in particular, but still needs to mature to the appropriate setting of its contours. There is grace in relation to legislative establishment of objective criteria to enable judge, from the constitutional order, bring the legitimacy (the first step, as an abstract control of the law), for then, from the analysis of the case to exercise control of the adequate representation of the individual or entity legitimized.