Synthetic Unity as Gestalt: Gurwitsch’s reading of Gestalt Theory via Kant and Phenomenology

Detalhes bibliográficos
Autor(a) principal: Pereira dos Santos, Hernani
Data de Publicação: 2022
Tipo de documento: Artigo
Idioma: eng
Título da fonte: Phenomenology, Humanities and Sciences
Texto Completo: https://phenomenology.com.br/index.php/phe/article/view/126
Resumo: The main goal of this essay is to suggest that both Gurwitsch’s reinterpretation of phenomenology in Gestalt theory terms and his critical approach to Husserl are based on a fun-damental rereading of two Kant doctrines developed in his Critique of Pure Reason: the doc-trine of the synthetic unity of manifold and the doctrine of the synthetic unity of apperception. We propose that this indicates that the core concepts of Gestalt Psychology have been transcen-dentally structured. Ultimately, it allows for a critical approximation of Gestalt Psychology and transcendental phenomenology. In this regard, we will first revisit Kant’s Transcendental Deduc-tion and develop its nuclear moments as they pertain to the issue of synthesis. Second, we will demonstrate how Gurwitsch employs Gestalt Psychology in an epistemological sense, placing and presenting its premises in a remarkable framework, far from the original aims of its precur-sors. Finally, we will present how his reinterpretation of Gestalt Psychology implies the structure of Kant’s Transcendental Deduction and how it may be used to criticize idealistic assumptions found in diverse philosophical traditions, also including Kant and certain Husserl claims.
id UFPR-17_78527d46684e5b5d6a3c304e629dfd6d
oai_identifier_str oai:phenomenology.com.br:article/126
network_acronym_str UFPR-17
network_name_str Phenomenology, Humanities and Sciences
repository_id_str
spelling Synthetic Unity as Gestalt: Gurwitsch’s reading of Gestalt Theory via Kant and PhenomenologyLa Unidad Sintética como Gestalt: Gurwitsch y la Teoría Gestalt a Través de Kant y la FenomenologíaUnidade Sintética como Gestalt: Gurwitsch e a Teoria de Gestalt Via Kant e a FenomenologiaFenomenologiaFilosofiaPercepçãoPsicologia FenomenológicaPhenomenologyPhilosophyPerceptionPhenomenological PsychologyFenomenologíaFilosofíaPercepciónPsicología FenomenológicaThe main goal of this essay is to suggest that both Gurwitsch’s reinterpretation of phenomenology in Gestalt theory terms and his critical approach to Husserl are based on a fun-damental rereading of two Kant doctrines developed in his Critique of Pure Reason: the doc-trine of the synthetic unity of manifold and the doctrine of the synthetic unity of apperception. We propose that this indicates that the core concepts of Gestalt Psychology have been transcen-dentally structured. Ultimately, it allows for a critical approximation of Gestalt Psychology and transcendental phenomenology. In this regard, we will first revisit Kant’s Transcendental Deduc-tion and develop its nuclear moments as they pertain to the issue of synthesis. Second, we will demonstrate how Gurwitsch employs Gestalt Psychology in an epistemological sense, placing and presenting its premises in a remarkable framework, far from the original aims of its precur-sors. Finally, we will present how his reinterpretation of Gestalt Psychology implies the structure of Kant’s Transcendental Deduction and how it may be used to criticize idealistic assumptions found in diverse philosophical traditions, also including Kant and certain Husserl claims.El objetivo principal de este ensayo es sugerir que tanto la reinterpretación propuesta por Gurwitsch de la fenomenología en términos de la teoría de la Gestalt, así como su crítica a Husserl, se basan en una relectura fundamental de dos doctrinas desarrolladas por Kant en su Crítica de la razón pura: la doctrina de la unidad sintética de la diversidad de lo múltiple de las intuiciones sensibles y la de la unidad sintética de apercepción. Se propone que esto indica que los conceptos centrales de la Psicología Gestalt han sido estructurados de forma trascendental. En última instancia, esto permite un enfoque crítico de la Psicología Gestalt y la fenomenología trascendental. En este sentido, comenzará con una revisión de la Deducción Trascendental de Kant y con el despliegue de sus momentos nucleares relacionados con el tema de la síntesis. En segundo lugar, intentará demostrar cómo Gurwitsch emplea la Psicología Gestalt en un sentido epistemológico, colocando y presentando sus premisas en un marco teórico singular, aunque le-jos de los objetivos originales de sus precursores. Finalmente, presentará cómo su interpretación de la Psicología Gestalt implica la estructura de la Deducción Trascendental de Kant y cómo se puede utilizar para una crítica de los supuestos idealistas que se pueden encontrar en diferentes tradiciones filosóficas, que también incluyen a Kant y algunas de las teorías de Husserl.O principal objetivo deste ensaio é sugerir que a reinterpretação proposta por Gurwits-ch da fenomenologia em termos da Teoria da Gestalt, bem como a sua crítica a Husserl, baseiam--se em uma releitura substantiva de duas doutrinas desenvolvidas por Kant em sua Crítica da Razão Pura: a doutrina da unidade sintética do múltiplo sensível e aquela da unidade sintética da apercepção. Propõe-se que isto indica que os conceitos centrais da Psicologia da Gestalt tenham sido estruturados de forma transcendental. Em última instância, isto permite uma aproximação crítica de Psicologia da Gestalt e fenomenologia transcendental. A este respeito, começar-se-á com uma revisão da Dedução Transcendental de Kant e com o desdobramento de seus momen-tos nucleares relacionados com a questão da síntese. Em segundo lugar, procurar-se-á demons-trar como Gurwitsch emprega a Psicologia da Gestalt em um sentido epistemológico, colocando e apresentando as suas premissas em um quadro teórico singular, distante dos objetivos originais de seus precursores. Finalmente, apresentar-se-á como a sua interpretação da Psicologia da Ges-talt implica a estrutura da Dedução Transcendental de Kant e como ela pode ser usada para uma crítica de pressupostos idealistas que podem ser encontrados em diferentes tradições filosóficas, que incluem, também, Kant e algumas teorias de Husserl.Associação de Pesquisas em Fenomenologia (APFeno)2022-06-22info:eu-repo/semantics/articleinfo:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersionTextoTextoinfo:eu-repo/semantics/otherapplication/pdfhttps://phenomenology.com.br/index.php/phe/article/view/126Phenomenology, Humanities and Sciences; Vol. 2 No. 2 (2021): Dossiê Especial Aron Gurwitsch; 229-240Phenomenology, Humanities and Sciences; Vol. 2 Núm. 2 (2021): Dossiê Especial Aron Gurwitsch; 229-240Phenomenology, Humanities and Sciences; v. 2 n. 2 (2021): Dossiê Especial Aron Gurwitsch; 229-2402675-4673reponame:Phenomenology, Humanities and Sciencesinstname:Universidade Federal do Paraná (UFPR)instacron:UFPRenghttps://phenomenology.com.br/index.php/phe/article/view/126/77Copyright (c) 2022 Phenomenology, Humanities and Sciencesinfo:eu-repo/semantics/openAccessPereira dos Santos, Hernani2024-04-15T18:43:59Zoai:phenomenology.com.br:article/126Revistahttps://phenomenology.com.br/index.php/phePUBhttps://phenomenology.com.br/index.php/index/oaicontato@phenomenology.com.br || aholanda@yahoo.com2675-46732675-4673opendoar:2024-04-15T18:43:59Phenomenology, Humanities and Sciences - Universidade Federal do Paraná (UFPR)false
dc.title.none.fl_str_mv Synthetic Unity as Gestalt: Gurwitsch’s reading of Gestalt Theory via Kant and Phenomenology
La Unidad Sintética como Gestalt: Gurwitsch y la Teoría Gestalt a Través de Kant y la Fenomenología
Unidade Sintética como Gestalt: Gurwitsch e a Teoria de Gestalt Via Kant e a Fenomenologia
title Synthetic Unity as Gestalt: Gurwitsch’s reading of Gestalt Theory via Kant and Phenomenology
spellingShingle Synthetic Unity as Gestalt: Gurwitsch’s reading of Gestalt Theory via Kant and Phenomenology
Pereira dos Santos, Hernani
Fenomenologia
Filosofia
Percepção
Psicologia Fenomenológica
Phenomenology
Philosophy
Perception
Phenomenological Psychology
Fenomenología
Filosofía
Percepción
Psicología Fenomenológica
title_short Synthetic Unity as Gestalt: Gurwitsch’s reading of Gestalt Theory via Kant and Phenomenology
title_full Synthetic Unity as Gestalt: Gurwitsch’s reading of Gestalt Theory via Kant and Phenomenology
title_fullStr Synthetic Unity as Gestalt: Gurwitsch’s reading of Gestalt Theory via Kant and Phenomenology
title_full_unstemmed Synthetic Unity as Gestalt: Gurwitsch’s reading of Gestalt Theory via Kant and Phenomenology
title_sort Synthetic Unity as Gestalt: Gurwitsch’s reading of Gestalt Theory via Kant and Phenomenology
author Pereira dos Santos, Hernani
author_facet Pereira dos Santos, Hernani
author_role author
dc.contributor.author.fl_str_mv Pereira dos Santos, Hernani
dc.subject.por.fl_str_mv Fenomenologia
Filosofia
Percepção
Psicologia Fenomenológica
Phenomenology
Philosophy
Perception
Phenomenological Psychology
Fenomenología
Filosofía
Percepción
Psicología Fenomenológica
topic Fenomenologia
Filosofia
Percepção
Psicologia Fenomenológica
Phenomenology
Philosophy
Perception
Phenomenological Psychology
Fenomenología
Filosofía
Percepción
Psicología Fenomenológica
description The main goal of this essay is to suggest that both Gurwitsch’s reinterpretation of phenomenology in Gestalt theory terms and his critical approach to Husserl are based on a fun-damental rereading of two Kant doctrines developed in his Critique of Pure Reason: the doc-trine of the synthetic unity of manifold and the doctrine of the synthetic unity of apperception. We propose that this indicates that the core concepts of Gestalt Psychology have been transcen-dentally structured. Ultimately, it allows for a critical approximation of Gestalt Psychology and transcendental phenomenology. In this regard, we will first revisit Kant’s Transcendental Deduc-tion and develop its nuclear moments as they pertain to the issue of synthesis. Second, we will demonstrate how Gurwitsch employs Gestalt Psychology in an epistemological sense, placing and presenting its premises in a remarkable framework, far from the original aims of its precur-sors. Finally, we will present how his reinterpretation of Gestalt Psychology implies the structure of Kant’s Transcendental Deduction and how it may be used to criticize idealistic assumptions found in diverse philosophical traditions, also including Kant and certain Husserl claims.
publishDate 2022
dc.date.none.fl_str_mv 2022-06-22
dc.type.driver.fl_str_mv info:eu-repo/semantics/article
info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
Texto
Texto
info:eu-repo/semantics/other
format article
status_str publishedVersion
dc.identifier.uri.fl_str_mv https://phenomenology.com.br/index.php/phe/article/view/126
url https://phenomenology.com.br/index.php/phe/article/view/126
dc.language.iso.fl_str_mv eng
language eng
dc.relation.none.fl_str_mv https://phenomenology.com.br/index.php/phe/article/view/126/77
dc.rights.driver.fl_str_mv Copyright (c) 2022 Phenomenology, Humanities and Sciences
info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
rights_invalid_str_mv Copyright (c) 2022 Phenomenology, Humanities and Sciences
eu_rights_str_mv openAccess
dc.format.none.fl_str_mv application/pdf
dc.publisher.none.fl_str_mv Associação de Pesquisas em Fenomenologia (APFeno)
publisher.none.fl_str_mv Associação de Pesquisas em Fenomenologia (APFeno)
dc.source.none.fl_str_mv Phenomenology, Humanities and Sciences; Vol. 2 No. 2 (2021): Dossiê Especial Aron Gurwitsch; 229-240
Phenomenology, Humanities and Sciences; Vol. 2 Núm. 2 (2021): Dossiê Especial Aron Gurwitsch; 229-240
Phenomenology, Humanities and Sciences; v. 2 n. 2 (2021): Dossiê Especial Aron Gurwitsch; 229-240
2675-4673
reponame:Phenomenology, Humanities and Sciences
instname:Universidade Federal do Paraná (UFPR)
instacron:UFPR
instname_str Universidade Federal do Paraná (UFPR)
instacron_str UFPR
institution UFPR
reponame_str Phenomenology, Humanities and Sciences
collection Phenomenology, Humanities and Sciences
repository.name.fl_str_mv Phenomenology, Humanities and Sciences - Universidade Federal do Paraná (UFPR)
repository.mail.fl_str_mv contato@phenomenology.com.br || aholanda@yahoo.com
_version_ 1796798427834613760