The proposal of hybrid teaching from Parecer CNE/CP 14/22 and the precariousness of teacher training

Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Nardim, Thaise Luciane
Publication Date: 2023
Other Authors: Pereira da Costa, Leonardo
Format: Article
Language: por
Source: Revista Brasileira de Educação do Campo
Download full: https://sistemas.uft.edu.br/periodicos/index.php/campo/article/view/15370
Summary: ABSTRACT. The object of study of this text is the Parecer 14/22, an assent issued by the National Council of Education that establishes guidelines for the implementation of blended learning in Brazilian Higher Education. The research aimed to verify the notion of hybrid teaching proposed implicitly by the opinion, to make explicit its social, cultural, and ideological connections and predict the impacts of this alignment on pedagogical work. Through a critical document analysis supported by critical discourse analysis procedures, it questions the notion of blended learning built into the document, revealing its links to the flexible accumulation’s educational discourse. The paper points out elements in the textual construction and shows that the flexibility of teaching spaces and times operated by digital information and communication technologies mediation, as proposed in the document, would favor the implementation of a pedagogy of competencies aligned with hegemonic ideological perspectives. It also evidences that the articulation between these factors would lead to the impairment and precariousness of teacher training, impacting the guarantee of the right to education and perpetuating inequality and exclusion of the working class. Thus, the text concludes that there is an urgent need for education workers to lead the debate on the use of contemporary technologies in teaching, considering work as an educational principle and maintaining the centrality of the proposals in the teacher-student pedagogical relationship.
id UFT-5_aa0b2f2d8d895c4fb1444245151b10ed
oai_identifier_str oai:ojs.revista.uft.edu.br:article/15370
network_acronym_str UFT-5
network_name_str Revista Brasileira de Educação do Campo
repository_id_str
spelling The proposal of hybrid teaching from Parecer CNE/CP 14/22 and the precariousness of teacher trainingThe proposal of hybrid teaching from Parecer CNE/CP 14/22 and the precariousness of teacher trainingLa propuesta de enseñanza semipresencial del Parecer CNE/CP 14/22: hacer precaria a la formación docenteThe proposal of hybrid teaching from Parecer CNE/CP 14/22 and the precariousness of teacher trainingA proposta de ensino híbrido do Parecer CNE/CP 14/22 e a precarização da formação docenteABSTRACT. The object of study of this text is the Parecer 14/22, an assent issued by the National Council of Education that establishes guidelines for the implementation of blended learning in Brazilian Higher Education. The research aimed to verify the notion of hybrid teaching proposed implicitly by the opinion, to make explicit its social, cultural, and ideological connections and predict the impacts of this alignment on pedagogical work. Through a critical document analysis supported by critical discourse analysis procedures, it questions the notion of blended learning built into the document, revealing its links to the flexible accumulation’s educational discourse. The paper points out elements in the textual construction and shows that the flexibility of teaching spaces and times operated by digital information and communication technologies mediation, as proposed in the document, would favor the implementation of a pedagogy of competencies aligned with hegemonic ideological perspectives. It also evidences that the articulation between these factors would lead to the impairment and precariousness of teacher training, impacting the guarantee of the right to education and perpetuating inequality and exclusion of the working class. Thus, the text concludes that there is an urgent need for education workers to lead the debate on the use of contemporary technologies in teaching, considering work as an educational principle and maintaining the centrality of the proposals in the teacher-student pedagogical relationship.ABSTRACT. The object of study of this text is the Parecer 14/22, an assent issued by the National Council of Education that establishes guidelines for the implementation of blended learning in Brazilian Higher Education. The research aimed to verify the notion of hybrid teaching proposed implicitly by the opinion, to make explicit its social, cultural, and ideological connections and predict the impacts of this alignment on pedagogical work. Through a critical document analysis supported by critical discourse analysis procedures, it questions the notion of blended learning built into the document, revealing its links to the flexible accumulation’s educational discourse. The paper points out elements in the textual construction and shows that the flexibility of teaching spaces and times operated by digital information and communication technologies mediation, as proposed in the document, would favor the implementation of a pedagogy of competencies aligned with hegemonic ideological perspectives. It also evidences that the articulation between these factors would lead to the impairment and precariousness of teacher training, impacting the guarantee of the right to education and perpetuating inequality and exclusion of the working class. Thus, the text concludes that there is an urgent need for education workers to lead the debate on the use of contemporary technologies in teaching, considering work as an educational principle and maintaining the centrality of the proposals in the teacher-student pedagogical relationship.RESUMEN. El objeto de estudio de este texto es el Parecer 14/22, un dictamen emitido por el Consejo Nacional de Educación que establece directrices para la implementación, en la Educación Superior brasileña, de la enseñanza semipresencial. La investigación tuvo como objetivo verificar la noción de enseñanza semipresencial propuesta de forma subyacente por el parecer, con el fin de explicitar sus vinculaciones sociales, culturales e ideológicas y prever los impactos de esta alineación en el trabajo pedagógico. A través de un análisis crítico-documental respaldado por procedimientos de análisis crítico del discurso, cuestiona la noción de enseñanza híbrida construida en el documento y revela su vínculo con el discurso educativo de la acumulación flexible. El artículo señala elementos presentes en la construcción textual; demuestra sus implicaciones en el proceso social y muestra que la flexibilización de los espacios y tiempos de enseñanza operados por la mediación de las tecnologías digitales de la información y la comunicación, tal como se propone en el dictamen, favorecería la implementación de una pedagogía de competencias alineada con perspectivas ideológicas hegemónicas. También evidencia que la articulación entre estos factores llevaría a la racionalización y precarización de la formación docente, impactando en la garantía del derecho a la educación y perpetuando la desigualdad y exclusión de la clase trabajadora. Así, el texto concluye que urge que los trabajadores de la educación retomen el debate sobre el uso de las tecnologías contemporáneas en la enseñanza, considerando el trabajo como principio educativo y manteniendo la centralidad de las propuestas en la relación pedagógica docente-alumno.ABSTRACT. The object of study of this text is the Parecer 14/22, an assent issued by the National Council of Education that establishes guidelines for the implementation of blended learning in Brazilian Higher Education. The research aimed to verify the notion of hybrid teaching proposed implicitly by the opinion, to make explicit its social, cultural, and ideological connections and predict the impacts of this alignment on pedagogical work. Through a critical document analysis supported by critical discourse analysis procedures, it questions the notion of blended learning built into the document, revealing its links to the flexible accumulation’s educational discourse. The paper points out elements in the textual construction and shows that the flexibility of teaching spaces and times operated by digital information and communication technologies mediation, as proposed in the document, would favor the implementation of a pedagogy of competencies aligned with hegemonic ideological perspectives. It also evidences that the articulation between these factors would lead to the impairment and precariousness of teacher training, impacting the guarantee of the right to education and perpetuating inequality and exclusion of the working class. Thus, the text concludes that there is an urgent need for education workers to lead the debate on the use of contemporary technologies in teaching, considering work as an educational principle and maintaining the centrality of the proposals in the teacher-student pedagogical relationship.Este texto tem por objeto de estudo o Parecer 14/22, documento emitido pelo Conselho Nacional de Educação que avalia o projeto de resolução das diretrizes para a implantação do ensino híbrido no Ensino Superior brasileiro. A pesquisa teve como objetivo verificar a noção de ensino híbrido proposta de modo subjacente pelo parecer, a fim de explicitar suas vinculações sociais, culturais e ideológicas e antever possíveis impactos desse alinhamento no trabalho pedagógico.  Por meio de uma análise crítico-documental amparada por procedimentos da análise crítica do discurso, interpelam-se as proposições teóricas do documento, de modo a desvelar sua vinculação ao discurso educacional próprio do regime de acumulação flexível. Apontando elementos presentes na construção textual e demonstrando suas implicações no processo social, o artigo evidencia que a flexibilização de espaços e tempos de ensino operada pela mediação de tecnologias digitais de informação e comunicação, se realizada conforme a proposição do parecer, favorece a implantação de uma pedagogia das competências alinhada a perspectivas ideológicas hegemônicas. Mostra, ainda, que a articulação entre esses fatores conduziria ao aligeiramento e à precarização da formação docente, impactando na garantia do direito à educação e perpetuando a desigualdade e a exclusão da classe trabalhadora. Assim, o texto conclui pela urgência de que os trabalhadores da educação assumam o debate sobre a utilização de tecnologias contemporâneas no ensino, tomando o conceito de trabalho como princípio educativo e mantendo a centralidade das propostas na relação pedagógica professor-aluno. Palavras-chave: educação e trabalho, educação e tecnologia, ensino híbrido, formação de professores, política educacional.   The proposal of hybrid teaching from Parecer CNE/CP 14/22 and the precariousness of teacher training ABSTRACT. The object of study of this text is the Parecer 14/22, an assent issued by the National Council of Education that establishes guidelines for the implementation of blended learning in Brazilian Higher Education. The research aimed to verify the notion of hybrid teaching proposed implicitly by the opinion, to make explicit its social, cultural, and ideological connections and predict the impacts of this alignment on pedagogical work. Through a critical document analysis supported by critical discourse analysis procedures, it questions the notion of blended learning built into the document, revealing its links to the flexible accumulation’s educational discourse. The paper points out elements in the textual construction and shows that the flexibility of teaching spaces and times operated by digital information and communication technologies mediation, as proposed in the document, would favor the implementation of a pedagogy of competencies aligned with hegemonic ideological perspectives. It also evidences that the articulation between these factors would lead to the impairment and precariousness of teacher training, impacting the guarantee of the right to education and perpetuating inequality and exclusion of the working class. Thus, the text concludes that there is an urgent need for education workers to lead the debate on the use of contemporary technologies in teaching, considering work as an educational principle and maintaining the centrality of the proposals in the teacher-student pedagogical relationship. Keywords: education and work, education and technology, blended learning, teacher training, educational policy.   La propuesta de enseñanza semipresencial del Parecer CNE/CP 14/22: hacer precaria a la formación docente RESUMEN. El objeto de estudio de este texto es el Parecer 14/22, un dictamen emitido por el Consejo Nacional de Educación que establece directrices para la implementación, en la Educación Superior brasileña, de la enseñanza semipresencial. La investigación tuvo como objetivo verificar la noción de enseñanza semipresencial propuesta de forma subyacente por el parecer, con el fin de explicitar sus vinculaciones sociales, culturales e ideológicas y prever los impactos de esta alineación en el trabajo pedagógico. A través de un análisis crítico-documental respaldado por procedimientos de análisis crítico del discurso, cuestiona la noción de enseñanza híbrida construida en el documento y revela su vínculo con el discurso educativo de la acumulación flexible. El artículo señala elementos presentes en la construcción textual; demuestra sus implicaciones en el proceso social y muestra que la flexibilización de los espacios y tiempos de enseñanza operados por la mediación de las tecnologías digitales de la información y la comunicación, tal como se propone en el dictamen, favorecería la implementación de una pedagogía de competencias alineada con perspectivas ideológicas hegemónicas. También evidencia que la articulación entre estos factores llevaría a la racionalización y precarización de la formación docente, impactando en la garantía del derecho a la educación y perpetuando la desigualdad y exclusión de la clase trabajadora. Así, el texto concluye que urge que los trabajadores de la educación retomen el debate sobre el uso de las tecnologías contemporáneas en la enseñanza, considerando el trabajo como principio educativo y manteniendo la centralidad de las propuestas en la relación pedagógica docente-alumno. Palabras clave: educación y trabajo, educación y tecnología semipresencial, formación docente, política educativa.Universidade Federal do Tocantins2023-10-21info:eu-repo/semantics/articleinfo:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersionapplication/pdfhttps://sistemas.uft.edu.br/periodicos/index.php/campo/article/view/1537010.20873/uft.rbec.e15370Brazilian Journal of Rural Education; Bd. 8 (2023): Publicação Contínua / Continuous Publication; e15370Brazilian Journal of Rural Education; Vol. 8 (2023): Publicação Contínua / Continuous Publication; e15370Revista Brasileña de Educación Rural; Vol. 8 (2023): Publicação Contínua / Continuous Publication; e15370Brazilian Journal of Rural Education; Vol. 8 (2023): Publicação Contínua / Continuous Publication; e15370Revista Brasileira de Educação do Campo; v. 8 (2023): Publicação Contínua / Continuous Publication; e153702525-4863reponame:Revista Brasileira de Educação do Campoinstname:Universidade Federal do Tocantins (UFT)instacron:UFTporhttps://sistemas.uft.edu.br/periodicos/index.php/campo/article/view/15370/21690Copyright (c) 2023 Thaise Luciane Nardim, Leonardo Pereira da Costahttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccessNardim, Thaise LucianePereira da Costa, Leonardo2024-03-25T18:08:09Zoai:ojs.revista.uft.edu.br:article/15370Revistahttps://sistemas.uft.edu.br/periodicos/index.php/campoPUBhttps://sistemas.uft.edu.br/periodicos/index.php/campo/oaigustavo.araujo@uft.edu.br||rbec@uft.edu.br||gustavo.araujo@uft.edu.br|| rbec@uft.edu.br2525-48632525-4863opendoar:2024-03-25T18:08:09Revista Brasileira de Educação do Campo - Universidade Federal do Tocantins (UFT)false
dc.title.none.fl_str_mv The proposal of hybrid teaching from Parecer CNE/CP 14/22 and the precariousness of teacher training
The proposal of hybrid teaching from Parecer CNE/CP 14/22 and the precariousness of teacher training
La propuesta de enseñanza semipresencial del Parecer CNE/CP 14/22: hacer precaria a la formación docente
The proposal of hybrid teaching from Parecer CNE/CP 14/22 and the precariousness of teacher training
A proposta de ensino híbrido do Parecer CNE/CP 14/22 e a precarização da formação docente
title The proposal of hybrid teaching from Parecer CNE/CP 14/22 and the precariousness of teacher training
spellingShingle The proposal of hybrid teaching from Parecer CNE/CP 14/22 and the precariousness of teacher training
Nardim, Thaise Luciane
title_short The proposal of hybrid teaching from Parecer CNE/CP 14/22 and the precariousness of teacher training
title_full The proposal of hybrid teaching from Parecer CNE/CP 14/22 and the precariousness of teacher training
title_fullStr The proposal of hybrid teaching from Parecer CNE/CP 14/22 and the precariousness of teacher training
title_full_unstemmed The proposal of hybrid teaching from Parecer CNE/CP 14/22 and the precariousness of teacher training
title_sort The proposal of hybrid teaching from Parecer CNE/CP 14/22 and the precariousness of teacher training
author Nardim, Thaise Luciane
author_facet Nardim, Thaise Luciane
Pereira da Costa, Leonardo
author_role author
author2 Pereira da Costa, Leonardo
author2_role author
dc.contributor.author.fl_str_mv Nardim, Thaise Luciane
Pereira da Costa, Leonardo
description ABSTRACT. The object of study of this text is the Parecer 14/22, an assent issued by the National Council of Education that establishes guidelines for the implementation of blended learning in Brazilian Higher Education. The research aimed to verify the notion of hybrid teaching proposed implicitly by the opinion, to make explicit its social, cultural, and ideological connections and predict the impacts of this alignment on pedagogical work. Through a critical document analysis supported by critical discourse analysis procedures, it questions the notion of blended learning built into the document, revealing its links to the flexible accumulation’s educational discourse. The paper points out elements in the textual construction and shows that the flexibility of teaching spaces and times operated by digital information and communication technologies mediation, as proposed in the document, would favor the implementation of a pedagogy of competencies aligned with hegemonic ideological perspectives. It also evidences that the articulation between these factors would lead to the impairment and precariousness of teacher training, impacting the guarantee of the right to education and perpetuating inequality and exclusion of the working class. Thus, the text concludes that there is an urgent need for education workers to lead the debate on the use of contemporary technologies in teaching, considering work as an educational principle and maintaining the centrality of the proposals in the teacher-student pedagogical relationship.
publishDate 2023
dc.date.none.fl_str_mv 2023-10-21
dc.type.driver.fl_str_mv info:eu-repo/semantics/article
info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion
format article
status_str publishedVersion
dc.identifier.uri.fl_str_mv https://sistemas.uft.edu.br/periodicos/index.php/campo/article/view/15370
10.20873/uft.rbec.e15370
url https://sistemas.uft.edu.br/periodicos/index.php/campo/article/view/15370
identifier_str_mv 10.20873/uft.rbec.e15370
dc.language.iso.fl_str_mv por
language por
dc.relation.none.fl_str_mv https://sistemas.uft.edu.br/periodicos/index.php/campo/article/view/15370/21690
dc.rights.driver.fl_str_mv Copyright (c) 2023 Thaise Luciane Nardim, Leonardo Pereira da Costa
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0
info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
rights_invalid_str_mv Copyright (c) 2023 Thaise Luciane Nardim, Leonardo Pereira da Costa
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0
eu_rights_str_mv openAccess
dc.format.none.fl_str_mv application/pdf
dc.publisher.none.fl_str_mv Universidade Federal do Tocantins
publisher.none.fl_str_mv Universidade Federal do Tocantins
dc.source.none.fl_str_mv Brazilian Journal of Rural Education; Bd. 8 (2023): Publicação Contínua / Continuous Publication; e15370
Brazilian Journal of Rural Education; Vol. 8 (2023): Publicação Contínua / Continuous Publication; e15370
Revista Brasileña de Educación Rural; Vol. 8 (2023): Publicação Contínua / Continuous Publication; e15370
Brazilian Journal of Rural Education; Vol. 8 (2023): Publicação Contínua / Continuous Publication; e15370
Revista Brasileira de Educação do Campo; v. 8 (2023): Publicação Contínua / Continuous Publication; e15370
2525-4863
reponame:Revista Brasileira de Educação do Campo
instname:Universidade Federal do Tocantins (UFT)
instacron:UFT
instname_str Universidade Federal do Tocantins (UFT)
instacron_str UFT
institution UFT
reponame_str Revista Brasileira de Educação do Campo
collection Revista Brasileira de Educação do Campo
repository.name.fl_str_mv Revista Brasileira de Educação do Campo - Universidade Federal do Tocantins (UFT)
repository.mail.fl_str_mv gustavo.araujo@uft.edu.br||rbec@uft.edu.br||gustavo.araujo@uft.edu.br|| rbec@uft.edu.br
_version_ 1798319754515054592